Me, myself and I: perceptions of social capital for mothers
ageing out of the child welfare system
Melissa Radey*, Lisa Schelbe*, Lenore M. McWey† and Kendal Holtrop†
*Florida State University, College of Social Work, Tallahassee, FL, USA, and †Florida State University, College of Human
Sciences, Tallahassee, FL, USA
Correspondence:
Melissa Radey, Florida State
University, College of Social Work,
296 Champions Way, Tallahassee, FL,
32306, USA.
Email: mradey@fsu.edu
Keywords: child welfare, leaving care,
parenting/parenthood, social support,
unmarried mothers
Accepted for publication: July 2016
ABSTRACT
Youth ageing out of the child welfare system become parents at rates
two to three times higher than their non-child welfare system involved
peers. Substantial literature acknowledges that youth ageing out who
are parenting are vulnerable; yet, little is known about their lived
experiences. Social capital, or the actual or potential resources available
from one’s network, can provide essential resources for the wellbeing of
parents ageing out. This qualitative study examined social capital of
mothers ageing out from the perspectives of both mothers and service
providers. We conducted small group interviews with 13 mothers
ageing out and 14 service providers. Data were analysed using thematic
analysis. Findings revealed the use of a social capital framework
delineates that mothers lacked beneficial social relationships and,
consequently, support. A lack of trust coupled with a desire to break
intergenerational patterns and norms contributed to understanding
why mothers ageing out may not capitalize on resources that providers
often considered available. Based on findings, we conclude that
providing mothers ageing out with additional opportunities to develop
trust, positive relationships with mentors and extended services may
help to disrupt intergenerational patterns of maltreatment and promote
child and family wellbeing.
MOTHERS AGEING OUT OF THE CHILD WELFARE
SYSTEM
Youth ageing out of the child welfare system are signifi-
cantly more likely than their peers to become parents at
an early age. Studies have found that young women
ageing out become mothers at rates two to three times
higher than their non-child welfare system involved
peers (Courtney & Dworsky 2006; Shpiegel & Cascardi
2015). The Midwest Study found that 33% of woman
ageing out had been pregnant by age 18, and almost
50% had been pregnant by age 19, compared with
13.5% and 20% of their peers, respectively (Dworsky
& Courtney 2010). Additionally, repeat teen pregnancy
rates among youth ageing out are higher than those of
the general population (46% vs. 34%; Dworsky 2015).
The high rates of youth ageing out who become mothers,
or ‘mothers ageing out,’ is concerning because of the
challenging transition out of care youth already face
before the additional responsibility of caring for a child.
In addition, mothers ageing out may lack adequate skills
and resources to care for a child. Indeed, studies provide
evidence that mothers ageing out face higher rates of
child protective services involvement and child removal
(Dworsky 2015). These struggles are not unexpected,
considering many mothers ageing out have multiple risk
factors that are associated with child maltreatment
including adolescent parenting (e.g. Stevens-Simon
et al. 2001), poverty (e.g. Berger 2004) and parental
history of child maltreatment (e.g. Pears & Capaldi
2001). Despite the vulnerabilities that mothers ageing
out face, limited research has examined their day-to-
day experiences negotiating survival and parenthood in
the midst of ageing out (Radey et al. 2016).
Child and Family Social Work 2017, 22, pp 981–991 © 2016 John Wiley & Sons Ltd 981
doi:10.1111/cfs.12318