PHYSICAL REVIEW E 94, 042408 (2016)
Dielectrophoretic label-free immunoassay for rare-analyte quantification in biological samples
Logeeshan Velmanickam, Darrin Laudenbach, and Dharmakeerthi Nawarathna
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, North Dakota State University, Fargo, North Dakota, 58102-6050, USA
(Received 15 June 2016; published 11 October 2016)
The current gold standard for detecting or quantifying target analytes from blood samples is the ELISA
(enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay). The detection limit of ELISA is about 250 pg/ml. However, to quantify
analytes that are related to various stages of tumors including early detection requires detecting well below
the current limit of the ELISA test. For example, Interleukin 6 (IL-6) levels of early oral cancer patients are
<100 pg/ml and the prostate specific antigen level of the early stage of prostate cancer is about 1 ng/ml. Further, it
has been reported that there are significantly less than 1 pg/mL of analytes in the early stage of tumors. Therefore,
depending on the tumor type and the stage of the tumors, it is required to quantify various levels of analytes
ranging from ng/ml to pg/ml. To accommodate these critical needs in the current diagnosis, there is a need for a
technique that has a large dynamic range with an ability to detect extremely low levels of target analytes (<pg/ml).
To address this gap, we here report on a label-free, high-throughput technique based on dielectrophoresis. This
technique is capable of quantifying target analytes down to a few thousands of molecules (∼zmoles).
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.94.042408
I. INTRODUCTION
Immunoassays are utilized to detect or quantify target
biomolecules such as proteins, antigens, and antibodies in
biological samples [1,2]. Typically, in immunoassays, first the
specific target antibody is attached onto a solid surface of a
device or a traditional well plate. Second, the biological sample
that is containing the target molecules (analytes) is pipetted or
flowed over the antibodies allowing the analytes to conjugate
with antibodies. Finally, the presence of antibody-analyte
complexes is detected and the levels of target analytes in
the sample can be quantified [2,3]. For example, during the
diagnosis of tumors or when monitoring the progress of ongo-
ing treatments for tumors, it is required to monitor the levels
of representative tumor markers (proteins) in patients’ blood
[4,5]. This is typically performed through immunoassays, and
the current gold standard for detecting or quantifying target
analytes from blood samples is the ELISA (enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay). The ELISA uses antibody-analyte
conjugation followed by quantification of antibody-analyte
complexes in the sample [5]. The commonly used method for
quantifying antibody-analyte complexes involves measuring
the concentration (analyte) dependent color change or fluores-
cence intensity change in the sample. The detection limit of
ELISA is about 250 pg/ml [6]. However, to detect or quantify
analytes (proteins) that are related to various stages of tumors,
including early detection, requires detecting well below the
current limit of the ELISA. For example, Interleukin 6 (IL-6)
levels of early oral cancer patients are <100 pg/ml and the
prostate specific antigen (PSA) level of the early stage of
prostate cancer is about 1 ng/ml [7]. Further, it has been
reported that there are ≪pg/mL analytes in the early stage
of tumors [7]. Therefore, depending on the tumor type and
the stage of the tumors, various levels of analytes ranging
from ng/ml to pg/ml must be quantified [6,7]. Furthermore
levels of the number of protein targets (typically four to six
protein targets) must be detected or quantified in a single
experiment [8]. To accommodate these critical needs in the
current diagnosis, there is a need for a technique that has a
large dynamic range with an ability to detect extremely low
levels of target analytes (<pg/ml).
To address this critical need in biology and medicine, a
number of new techniques have been proposed and utilized.
Among the new techniques, impedimetric based analyte
detection or quantification offers a low cost and label-free
technique [8–11]. It uses an array of microelectrodes called
interdigitated electrodes that are fabricated on glass or similar
materials [12–14]. In impedimetric experiments, the change
of impedance upon binding the target analytes onto antibodies
that are immobilized on the electrodes or between electrodes
is measured at low frequencies (<1000 Hz). Using a standard
curve of known analyte concentration vs change in impedance,
the unknown analyte concentrations are calculated [13]. It has
been reported that the lowest analyte concentration that can
detect or quantify using this technique is about 80 pg/ml [8].
However, impedimetric based analyte detection or quantifica-
tion suffers a number of limitations, such as the following:
Impedance is dependent on the conductivity of the biological
sample, there is need for expensive electric circuits and equip-
ment (impedance analyzers) to record the impedance, and
impedance varies from one analyte type to another. In addition
to impedimetric based detection or quantification, there are
number of other techniques such as ion sensitive field-effect
transistors, semiconducting carbon nanotubes, thin-film gate
transistors, and electrolyte-insulator-semiconductor structures
that are available to detect or quantify target analytes of
a sample [8,15]. However, almost all of these techniques
require target analytes in very low ionic buffer solutions.
Therefore, these techniques have been used in applications
such as detecting DNA molecules and DNA hybridization
events in low-conductivity buffers. Furthermore, it has also
been reported that successful development of these techniques
for DNA analysis is much complex than expected. In particular,
the theoretical basis of the observed results, including a wide
variety of reported signal amplitudes and response times, still
remains unclear [15]. Therefore, these techniques have very
limited applicability in immunoassays. To address this gap,
we report here on a label-free, high-throughput technique
that is capable of detecting or quantifying target analytes
down to few thousands of molecules (∼zmoles). Furthermore,
our technique can be integrated with microfluidics chips for
2470-0045/2016/94(4)/042408(6) 042408-1 ©2016 American Physical Society