The end of the idyll? Post-crisis conservation and amenity migration
in natural protected areas
Jose A. Cortes-Vazquez
1
Sheffield Institute for International Development, University of Sheffield, 4th Floor ICOSS Building, 219 Portobello, Sheffield S1 4DP United Kingdom
article info
Article history:
Received 14 August 2016
Received in revised form
3 February 2017
Accepted 9 February 2017
abstract
The 2008 economic crisis and the introduction of austerity policies and values after the crisis are
transforming the management of natural protected areas in the global North. Communities of amenity
migrants living in these areas have been impacted by such issues as budgetary cuts and state disin-
vestments in conservation. Important threats to their expectations of an alternative life in a natural idyll
are changing the attitudes of amenity migrants towards conservation and rural regions. In this paper, I
analyse the main changes in their livelihood and lifestyles in two different natural parks in Spain. The
main goal of this analysis is to stimulate a debate about the social impacts of new conservation strategies
in the post-crisis context, with particular attention to multi-functional, post-productive rural spaces such
as amenity destinations.
© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The regime of economic austerity introduced in many countries
in the global North since the 2008 financial crisis is transforming
environmental policies and natural resource governance. This is
particularly evident in European natural protected areas. Reduction
of public funding, state disinvestments in conservation, prolifera-
tion of market-based conservation strategies, and institutional re-
arrangements are bringing profound changes to the management
of these areas amidst a scenario characterised by widespread eco-
nomic uncertainty and growing unemployment (Apostolopoulou
et al., 2014; Hodge and Adams, 2014; Apostolopoulou and Adams,
2015).
These changes are having a considerable impact on the lives and
livelihoods of amenity migrants, who at present constitute one of
the principal communities in natural protected areas in the global
North. Amenity migration, characterized by a move from cities to
rural areas in search of a higher quality of life (Moss, 2006; Abrams
et al., 2012), has become a relatively common phenomenon since
the 1970's.
2
Because amenity migrants are driven by the desire and
expectation of a more relaxed and carefree life closer to natural and
cultural amenities, rather than in response to economic or political
drivers (Gosnell and Abrams, 2010), it is usually considered a form
of lifestyle migration (Benson and O'Reilly, 2009).
This paper examines how the re-entrenchment of neoliberal
practices of natural resource governance in the post-crisis context,
notably in the form of state disinvestments in conservation, in-
teracts with ever-increasing economic constraints to generate
important impacts on the lifestyles of different communities of
amenity migrants in two natural parks in the south of Spain. The
study focuses on the outcomes of current changes in park man-
agement such as budgetary cuts to conservation practices, loss of
conservation jobs in environmental education and park mainte-
nance, and cancelation of state incentives to environmentally-
friendly activities such as ecotourism amidst a context of chang-
ing patterns in this sector that is causing decreasing incomes and
growing competition between ecotourism companies and between
workers.
My analysis approaches the social impacts of post-crisis con-
servation on amenity migrants from the point of view of their
lifestyles, for two interrelated reasons. First, amenity lifestyle is a
project, a search for an alternative life, not merely the result of a
move from the city to the countryside, and as such it depends on
the production of ‘rural idylls’ (Halfacree and Rivera, 2011). It is
therefore inextricably intertwined with the shifts in regimes of
production and consumption that were brought forth by the
introduction of conservation policies in many rural areas of Europe
E-mail address: jacorvaz@gmail.com.
1
Present address: Instituto de Ciencias del Patrimonio, CSIC, Av. de Vigo, Santiago
de Compostela, 15705 Spain.
2
Issues of amenity migration can be also found in such geographical contexts as
Latin America, although the bulk of case studies refer to European and North
American contexts (see Abrams et al., 2012 for a review).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Rural Studies
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jrurstud
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2017.02.005
0743-0167/© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Journal of Rural Studies 51 (2017) 115e124