CLINICAL ORTHOPAEDICS AND RELATED RESEARCH
Number 400, pp. 88–92
© 2002 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
88
Cadaveric Study of Glenohumeral
Translation Using
Electromagnetic Sensors
Mark T. Reis, MD**; James E. Tibone, MD**
,†
;
Patrick J. McMahon, MD*
,‡
; and Thay Q. Lee, PhD*
Clinical methods for measuring shoulder trans-
lation rely heavily on the experience of the ex-
aminer and remain largely subjective, prone to
errors of interobserver and intraobserver repro-
ducibility. Accurate in vitro methods of measur-
ing glenohumeral translation exist. The purpose
of the current study was to evaluate the accuracy
of computerized electromagnetic spatial sensors
applied to the skin, in measuring glenohumeral
translation under simulated conditions of a stan-
dard shoulder examination. Seven thawed, fresh-
frozen shoulder specimens from cadavers were
used in the study. Soft tissue and skin were not re-
moved. The specimens were mounted to simulate
clinical positions of patients having an antero-
posterior drawer or load-and-shift test. A series
of anterior and posterior displacements were
done manually under two conditions. Condition
I: Electromagnetic position sensors were taped to
skin and held beneath the examiner’s fingers;
and Condition II: Sensors were fixed rigidly to
pins inserted into the glenoid and humeral head,
respectively. Displacement values between condi-
tions, within trials, and among specimens were
compared for accuracy and reproducibility.
Strong agreement was shown between Condition
I and Condition II for the anterior and posterior
directions (interclass correlation coefficients 0.81
and 0.86, respectively). Simple linear regression
revealed a significant association between condi-
tions in the anterior and posterior directions. Re-
producibility between trials under each condition
was extremely high, with interclass correlation
coefficients greater than or equal to 0.98 regard-
less of direction of displacement or testing condi-
tion. The data from the current study show that
cutaneous application of electromagnetic posi-
tion sensors to the shoulder can accurately and
reproducibly measure true glenohumeral trans-
lation under testing conditions that mimic a stan-
dard, clinical shoulder examination.
Despite significant advances in understanding
of normal and pathologic glenohumeral transla-
tions, the magnitude of these translations in the
clinical setting remains difficult to quantify ac-
curately. Biomechanical research methods can
describe certain glenohumeral motions with
precision. The accuracy of electromagnetic spa-
tial sensors rigidly fixed to bone in measuring
joint displacement has been shown.
5,14
Such
measurement techniques are too invasive to be
considered for widespread clinical application.
In contrast, physical examination techniques for
From the *Orthopaedic Biomechanics Laboratory, VA
Healthcare System, Long Beach, CA, and University of
California, Irvine; the **Kerlan-Jobe Orthopaedic Clinic,
Los Angeles, CA; the
†
University of Southern California
Associates; and the
‡
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery,
University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA.
Reprint requests to Thay Q. Lee, PhD, Orthopaedic Bio-
mechanics Laboratory, VA Long Beach Healthcare System
(09/151), 5901 East 7th Street, Long Beach, CA 90822.