Force Analysis in Design of High Power Linear
Permanent Magnet Actuator with Gas Springs in
Drilling Applications
Ravindra Babu Ummaneni*, Robert Nilssen* and Brennvall.J.E**
*Department of Electrical Power Engineering
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway
**Resonator As, Trondheim, Norway
Abstract-This paper mainly describes the force analysis in the
design optimization of a reciprocating linear permanent magnet
actuator with interior magnet and slotless stator. This paper
predicts the force characteristics according to design parameters
such as pole pitch, magnet width and stator inner diameter on the
basis of numerical calculations.
The design is unique because of the combination of a heavy
piston and gas springs. The gas springs allow the piston to
oscillate at high frequency and with a long stroke length, in spite
of pistons large weight. A large electromagnetic force, due to the
use of permanent magnets makes a high power linear electric
actuator available. The heavy piston causes a considerable
vibration in the housing which is utilized in the drilling
application. The load can then be attached directly to the housing
and the machine can be made hermitically sealed, which eliminate
leakage problems. These features make the actuator suitable as a
hammer in oil drilling applications.
I. INTRODUCTION
A linear electric actuator is an electromagnetic device which
develops directly short travel oscillatory or progressive linear
motion. These devices would be advantageous in many
applications like compressors, pumps, electromagnetic valve
actuators, active shock absorbers, vibrators etc. In extension to
these applications the oscillatory motion of linear electrical
actuator can be effectively utilized in more demanding offshore
oil industry drilling applications.
Direct linear electro mechanical energy conversion devices
offer numerous advantages over their rotary to linear counter
parts, notably the absence of mechanical gears and
transmission systems, which result in a higher dynamic
performance and improved reliability. Among various linear
machine configurations, tubular machine with permanent
magnet excitation have a number of distinctive features [1],
such as high force density. Recently, many papers have been
published on the tubular linear machines include interior PM,
surface mounted PM and halbach pattern PM. An accurate
analytical field analysis of the tubular linear machines is
reported in [2], based on the Maxwell’s equations in cylindrical
coordinates. An overall comparison of interior and surface
mounted Tubular linear permanent magnet machine is well
discussed in [3]. Reviews on available drilling methods, new
concept in drilling applications using gas springs and well
known tubular linear permanent magnet machine technology
and magnetic analysis with different magnetizations are well
discussed in [4]. One of the proposed structures of the Linear
Permanent Magnet Actuator (LPMA) with interior magnet and
slotless stator, for example with three poles is shown in Fig.1
II. DRILLING TECHNOLOGY
Even though the rotary steerable systems are evolving
rapidly and delivering unprecedented rates of drilling
penetration, drillers nevertheless seek technology that speeds
the drilling process even more. Nowadays most of the down-
hole motors with rotating drill bits are driven by positive
displacement motors and down- hole turbine motors classified
depend upon the type of power sections used to convert the
hydraulic energy of high pressure fluid to mechanical energy in
the form of torque output. In these designs the power is
transmitted from power section to drill bit through different
mechanical arrangements like drive shaft, coupling assembly,
bearings etc. In the process of transmission part of the torque
developed is wasted, resulting in a reduced efficiency. In
addition, bearing stresses limits the transfer of possible forces
to the drill bit.
To overcome the difficulties in transfer of the power to
rotating drill bit there is lot of research going on to improve the
bearing designs. Furthermore, research focused on the
replacement of the rotary drilling bit with linear hammer. The
proposed linear permanent magnet actuator with gas springs
Fig.1 Linear permanent magnet actuator
285 1-4244-0743-5/07/$20.00 ©2007 IEEE