95
Review
www.expert-reviews.com ISSN 1476-0584 © 2011 Expert Reviews Ltd 10.1586/ERV.10.154
Vaccination remains an important public health
tool for disease control. Live vaccines typically
induce potent immune responses and complete
protection. However, live vaccines have been
associated with a number of safety concerns,
including reversion to virulence, resulting in
disease and other adverse effects ranging from
simple headache or fever (influenza, hepatitis A
and B, and yellow fever) to more severe enceph-
alitis (measles mumps rubella), intussusception
(rotavirus), vaccine-associated paralysis (polio)
or even death (smallpox) [1] . Primarily for safety
reasons, a major trend in vaccinology has been
to move towards the use of subunit vaccines,
which are composed of highly purified proteins
that can be targeted by the immune system.
However, the major drawback of subunit vac-
cines is that they are poorly immunogenic,
and often result in poor or suboptimal vaccine
efficacy. In order to be effective, subunit vac-
cines require coadministration with adjuvants.
With very few exceptions, currently available
vaccines contain a single adjuvant. Although
some vaccines with a single adjuvant provide
optimal protection, in many cases, the adjuvant
has a number of limitations, including induc-
tion of immune responses of low potency or
of inappropriate quality. This is especially the
case for human vaccines where there is a limited
choice of clinically approved adjuvants. Alum,
which was until recently the only clinically used
adjuvant in humans, typically induces Th2- but
not Th1-type immune responses, and therefore
does not induce sufficient protection from some
infections such as influenza. Even some promis-
ing experimental adjuvants have their own limi-
tations. Using multiple adjuvants in combina-
tion can overcome these limitations. Indeed,
there is evidence demonstrating that selected
adjuvant combinations can be complementary
or even synergistic. This approach may be ben-
eficial for improving a number of vaccines. For
example, addition of a Toll-like receptor (TLR)
agonist to an alum-containing vaccine may sig-
nificantly improve the efficacy of such a vac-
cine. As discussed later, a number of vaccines
containing various combinations of adjuvants
have been evaluated. This approach is promis-
ing and may improve a number of currently
available vaccines whose efficacy is less than
optimal. This approach may be particularly
beneficial for vaccines against specific popula-
tions, such as newborns and the elderly. In neo-
nates, vaccination generally induces a default
Th2 response and adjuvants that promote Th1
responses are required. Immune responses
decrease with advancing age, partly as a result
of thymic involution, which results in reduced
output of naive T cells [2] . Strong adjuvants
may provide an approach to boost immune
responses in the elderly. However, strong adju-
vant formulations have the potential to induce
undesirable side effects such as inflammation at
the injection site. Thus, rigorous safety evalu-
ations will be required for formulations based
on adjuvant combinations.
George Mutwiri
†1,2
,
Volker Gerdts
1
,
Sylvia van Drunen
Littel-van den Hurk
1,3
,
Gael Auray
1
,
Nelson Eng
1
,
Srinivas Garlapati
1
,
Lorne A Babiuk
4
and
Andrew Potter
1
1
Vaccines and Infectious Disease
Organization/International Vaccine
Center, University of Saskatchewan,
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan,
S7N 5E3, Canada
2
School of Public Health, University of
Saskatchewan, Saskatoon,
Saskatchewan, S7N 5E3, Canada
3
Microbiology and Immunology,
University of Saskatchewan,
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan,
S7N 5E3, Canada
4
University of Alberta, 3–7 University
Hall, Edmonton, AB, T6G 2J9, Canada
†
Author for correspondence:
Tel.: +1 306 966 1511
Fax: +1 306 966 7478
george.mutwiri@usask.ca
Adjuvants are critical components of many vaccines. The majority of existing vaccines contain
a single adjuvant. Owing to their inherent limitations, no single adjuvant is capable of inducing
all the protective immune responses required in the many different vaccines. Consequently,
investigators are exploring the potential of using formulations with multiple adjuvants in a
vaccine. An emerging paradigm is that careful selection of adjuvant combinations can result in
complementary and even synergistic enhancement of immune responses to vaccines. This
approach is promising and presents tremendous opportunities for vaccinologists to tailor immune
responses to specific vaccines. In this article, adjuvant combinations at different stages of
development will be reviewed.
KEYWORDS:adjuvants•deliverysystems•immunostimulators•vaccines
Combination adjuvants: the
next generation of adjuvants?
Expert Rev. Vaccines 10(1), 95–107 (2011)
For reprint orders, please contact reprints@expert-reviews.com