VOL. 95-B, No. 8, AUGUST 2013 1139
ONCOLOGY
Outcome of soft-tissue sarcoma patients who
were alive and event-free more than five
years after initial treatment
T. Nakamura,
R. J. Grimer,
S. R. Carter,
R. M. Tillman,
A. Abudu,
L. Jeys,
A. Sudo
From The Royal
Orthopaedic
Hospital,
Birmingham, United
Kingdom
T. Nakamura, MD, PhD,
Clinical Visitor
R. J. Grimer, FRCS, DCs,
Consultant, Professor
S. R. Carter, FRCS,
Consultant
R. M. Tillman, FRCS,
Consultant
A. Abudu, FRCS, Consultant
L. Jeys, FRCS, Consultant
The Royal Orthopaedic
Hospital, Oncology Service,
Bristol Road South,
Birmingham B31 2AP, UK.
A. Sudo, MD, PhD, Professor
Mie University Graduate
School of Medicine,
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery, Edobashi 2-174, Tsu-
city, Mie 514-8507, Japan.
Correspondence should be sent
to Dr T. Nakamura; e-mail:
tomoki66@clin.medic.mie-u.
ac.jp
©2013 The British Editorial
Society of Bone & Joint
Surgery
doi:10.1302/0301-620X.95B8.
31379 $2.00
Bone Joint J
2013;95-B:1139–43.
Received 28 November 2012;
Accepted after revision 10 April
2013
We evaluated the risk of late relapse and further outcome in patients with soft-tissue
sarcomas who were alive and event-free more than five years after initial treatment. From
our database we identified 1912 patients with these pathologies treated between 1980 and
2006. Of these 1912 patients, 603 were alive and event-free more than five years after initial
treatment and we retrospectively reviewed them. The mean age of this group was 48 years
(4 to 94) and 340 were men. The mean follow-up was 106 months (60 to 336). Of the original
cohort, 582 (97%) were alive at final follow-up. The disease-specific survival was 96.4% (95%
confidence interval (CI) 94.4 to 98.3) at ten years and 92.9% (95% CI 89 to 96.8) at 15 years.
The rate of late relapse was 6.3% (38 of 603). The ten- and 15-year event-free rates were
93.2% (95% CI 90.8 to 95.7) and 86.1% (95% CI 80.2 to 92.1), respectively. Multivariate
analysis showed that tumour size and tumour grade remained independent predictors of
events. In spite of further treatment, 19 of the 38 patients died of sarcoma. The three- and
five-year survival rates after the late relapse were 56.2% (95% CI 39.5 to 73.3) and 43.2%
(95% CI 24.7 to 61.7), respectively, with a median survival time of 46 months. Patients with
soft-tissue sarcoma, especially if large, require long-term follow-up, especially as they have
moderate potential to have their disease controlled.
Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2013;95-B:1139–43.
The overall survival rate of patients with all
stages of soft-tissue sarcoma remains between
50% and 60%.
1
Despite a complete surgical
resection having being performed, patients
with soft-tissue sarcomas may still develop dis-
tant metastases and recurrences at the site of
origin. The majority of patients who relapse
after their primary management do so within
the first two years, and more than 85% to
90% relapse within five years.
2-7
In contrast,
other authors suggest these patients have a
high incidence of relapse greater than five years
since the initial treatment (‘late relapse’), as
reflected in the difference between five- and
ten-year event-free survival.
5,6
However, few
studies have evaluated the occurrence of late
relapse and subsequent outcome in patients
who remain disease-free for at five years after
the initial treatment.
8
We have investigated this
latter subject and to examined the prognostic
factors associated with event-free survival.
Patients and Methods
From our database we identified 1912 patients
with a histological diagnosis of soft-tissue sar-
coma treated between 1980 and 2006. Patients
who presented with recurrent disease, distant
metastases at diagnosis or who were referred
for a second opinion were excluded from the
study. Of 1912 patients, 589 had relapsed
within five years after the initial treatment (of
these, 446 (75.7%) developed problems within
two years), and were excluded. A further
720 patients did not complete the five-year fol-
low-up: some had died of other causes, and
most did not live in our area. The remaining
603 patients were alive and event-free more
than five years after the initial treatment. The
mean age of this group was 48 years (4 to 94)
and 340 were men.
Among the 603 patients who comprised the
study cohort the mean follow-up was 106
months (median 97; 60 to 336). All patients
had pre-treatment staging with a lung CT scan
to rule out the presence of metastases. The his-
topathological diagnosis and tumour grade of
each patient was determined by independent
experienced musculoskeletal pathologists
using the French Federation of Cancer Centres
Sarcoma Group (FNCLCC) grading system.
9
Using the American Joint Committee on Can-
cer (AJCC) classification,
10
tumours were
defined as: 1) superficial (located exclusively
above the superficial fascia without invasion);
2) deep (located either exclusively beneath the
superficial fascia, superficial to the fascia with