Building Wireless Community Networks with
802.16 Standard
K. Sibanda, H.N. Muyingi and N. Mabanza
University of Fort Hare, Private Bag X1314, Alice 5700
Computer Science Department
ksibanda@ufh.ac.za , hmuying@ufh.ac.za , nmabanza@ufh.ac.za
Tel: +27 40 602 2464 +27 40 602 2230, Fax: +27 40 602 2464
Cell: +27 720 713 064 +27 82703922
Abstract— Network deployment in rural areas of developing
nations is a challenge to social conscience and technical capability
and affordability. Because most rural areas have no copper
telecommunication legacy, they can leapfrog to using wireless
technologies. These technologies allow "bypassing stages in
capacity building or investment through which countries were
previously required to pass during the process of economic
development [11]." In this work we discuss challenges of
deploying broadband networks in rural areas. WiMAX
technology is presented as a technology that can now provide
broadband connectivity in developing regions. We further discuss
Dwesa (SA) communication network which used WiMAX
technology to provide internet connectivity to a rural community
in the Eastern Cape, South Africa.
Keywords—WiMAX, Rural Areas, Connectivity, Technologies
I. INTRODUCTION
Wireless infrastructure growth can play a pivotal role in
economic growth and poverty reduction in rural communities.
It can also enhance social equity in terms of health security,
access to information, and improved education. However, the
reality is that extending network coverage to rural regions
remains a big challenge. Two wireless technologies, the
802.11 and the 802.16 standards, popularly referred to as WiFi
and WiMAX respectively have emerged as low cost
technologies to deploy networks in remote communities. This
has seen also a lot of debate on which technology provides the
lowest cost. The two should be considered as complementary
and not competing. WiFi technology was originally designed
for LANs, hence a number of challenges still limit its efficient
deployment for WANs. Some of those challenges include
small coverage area and low data rates as revealed in table 1.
It is shown in table 1 that WiMAX can cover larger areas
measured in km while WiFi can cover smaller areas measured
in m. WiMAX is scalable and can use all available frequencies
making it adaptable to any environment. The 802.16 standard
addresses all limitations of WiFi and can make high end
wireless a reality [3].
According to Lopez et al. [6] the right selection of the
wireless solution is determined by the technological capacity,
range, noise immunity, noise emission, security, setup and
running costs, power consumption, free versus licensed
operation, regulations, compatibility with hazardous
environment, fault tolerance, technological availability,
commercial availability and QoS.
Table 1: WiMAX versus WiFi
WiMAX WiFi Technical Differences
Range Up to 30 miles
typical cell size
of 4-6 miles
Sub-300 feet 802.16 tolerates
greater multi-path,
delay spread via
implementation of 256
FFT vs. 64FFT for
802.11
Coverage Outdoor NLOS-
performance
standard support
for advanced
antenna
techniques
Optimised for
indoor
performance,
short range
802.16 systems have
an overall higher
system gain,
delivering greater
penetration through
obstacles at longer
distances
Scalability Designed to
support
hundreds of
CPEs, with
unlimited
subscribers
behind each
CPE
Intended for LAN
applications,
users scale from
one to tens with
one subscriber for
each CPE device
802.16 can use all
available frequencies,
multiple channels
support cellular
deployment, 802.11 is
limited to license
exempt spectrum
Bit Rate 5bps/Hz peak up
to 100Mbp/s in
20 MHz channel
2.7 bps/Hz peak
up to 54Mbp/s in
20MHz channel
Higher modulations
coupled with flexible
error correction results
in more efficient use
of spectrum
For the purposes of our work, we discuss capacity, range,
setup and running costs, free versus licensed operation and
technological availability, however, works on noise immunity
can be found in [9], noise emission is discussed in [1]. There
are vast sources which deal with security issues including [5].
Third International Conference on Broadband Communications, Information Technology & Biomedical Applications
978-0-7695-3453-4/08 $25.00 © 2008 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/BROADCOM.2008.55
384