MATHEMATICS: TRADITIONS AND [NEW] PRACTICES • © AAMT & MERGA 2011
“MY SELF-ESTEEM HAS RISEN DRAMATICALLY”:
A CASE-STUDY OF PRE-SERVICE TEACHER ACTION
RESEARCH USING BIBLIOTHERAPY TO ADDRESS
MATHEMATICS ANXIETY
SUE WILSON
Australian Catholic University
sue.wilson@acu.edu.au
SHANNON GURNEY
Australian Catholic University
We read books to find out who we are. What other people, real or imaginary, do and think
and feel is an essential guide to our understanding of what we ourselves are and may
become. Ursula Le Guin
Pre-service primary teachers‟ mathematics anxiety affects their future teaching of
mathematics. This makes them less likely to engage with mathematics, impacting on the
attitudes and performance of their future students. Hence, teacher education is a crucial site
for further research. Bibliotherapy, incorporated into a fourth-year pre-service teacher‟s
action research during her final practicum, helped identify the impact of previous
experiences on her mathematical identity. With each cycle of her action research, supported
by the bibliotherapy process, the pre-service teacher was able to develop greater insight,
leading to a more positive projection into her future as a teacher of primary mathematics.
Introduction
Recent mathematics curriculum documents, for example, the Australian Curriculum
(Australian Curriculum and Assessment Authority [ACARA], 2010), are based on the
premise that all students are capable of learning mathematics. This counters the
traditional view, in which only a few students were expected to succeed. Mathematics
has been perceived as a critical filter (Sells, 1978), associated with elitism and social
stratification (Tate, 1995). Beliefs that success in mathematics relates to participants‟
inherent worth still dominate thinking (Gates & Jorgensen, 2009). Failure in
mathematics can have a powerful emotional impact that may extend far beyond the
mathematics classroom (Boaler, 1997). The impacts of mathematics instruction produce
for many an enduring state of mathematics anxiety. This anxiety has been associated
with inappropriate teaching practices, and a prevalent belief that success in mathematics
is determined by ability rather than effort (Stigler & Hiebert, 1992).
This paper, part of a larger project investigating the use of bibliotherapy, is written
within a framework of action research, as a tool for addressing primary pre-service
teachers‟ mathematics anxiety. This will add to existing frameworks for the study of
affect in mathematics education (see, for example, Hannula, Evans, Philippou, & Zan,
2004).
804