Freedom of the Press in Egypt:
Checks and Balances
Nathalie Bernard-Maugiron *
* Senior researcher at the Centre d'Etudes et de Documentation économique,
juridique et sociale (CEDEJ, Cairo).
On 20 May 2000, the Egyptian opposition paper El Shaab was shut down
following the freezing of the activities of the Labour Party due to internal
turmoil. In May 1995, a new press law nicknamed by its opponents "law on
the assassination of the press (qanun vnacthbahat al sahafa)" was adopted by
Parliament without prior debate. It severely limited freedom of the press by
amending the Penal Code, the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Press
Union Law. Following a protest campaign unleashed by the Press Syndicate,
the law was finally amended a year later by the 1996 Law on the Organization
of the Press. On 14 August 1999, three journalists were sentenced to two
years' imprisonment for having libelled a minister.
Although freedom of the press is guaranteed by the Egyptian Constitution,
and although many newspapers are issued and granted a great deal of indepen-
dence, the government during the last few years seems to have tried to
tighten the screw. It cannot be denied that the press under Hosni Mubarak
operates more freely than before. Government controls over the press have
been relaxed and restrictions on anti-government expression eased. A greater
respect has been shown for the rule of law: journalists are not put into prison
without trial and newspapers are not banned without a court ruling. When
personally attacked in the press, public officials take legal action in the courts
or respond in the press to defend themselves. Control on the press is,
however, maintained by legal means: the conditions for obtaining a publishing
licence may be almost impossible to fulfil; the licence may be withdrawn and
journalists may be condemned to harsh penalties and jailed for press offences.
More subtle extra-legal means of pressure also exist, such as denying a certain
category of journalists access to information.