1 3
Med Biol Eng Comput
DOI 10.1007/s11517-015-1295-6
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Influence of head mass on temporo-parietal skull impact using
finite element modeling
Debasis Sahoo
1
· Caroline Deck
1
· Narayan Yoganandan
2
· Rémy Willinger
1
Received: 27 January 2014 / Accepted: 1 April 2015
© International Federation for Medical and Biological Engineering 2015
1 Introduction
The biomechanical response of human head in pedestrian
accidents and side-impact motor vehicle crashes leads to
temporo-parietal skull fractures in some of the cases [17,
28, 34]. Due to the proximity of interior components of
vehicle, the temporo-parietal region of human head often
involves in contact during lateral motor vehicle impact
[7]. Around 95 % of all diffuse axonal injury (DAI) cases
are associated with head contact to the interior surface of
the vehicle [29]. Limited studies are reported in the litera-
ture in the context of trauma biomechanics of lateral head
impact [1, 7, 18, 28, 29]. In contrast to lateral region of
head, the frontal impact has been investigated more often,
and current regulatory injury criteria adopted worldwide
were derived from the integration of the resultant linear
acceleration at the center of gravity of head [15]. How-
ever, injury criteria derived for frontal impacts may exceed
its limits during side impacts, mostly occurred in vehicle
crashes [28]. Hence, the applicability of these criteria to
temporo-parietal impacts is not promising during side-
impact motor vehicle crashes [7]. In-depth study in this
field can provide better understanding of skull fracture
mechanism and emphasis on the tolerance of the skull to
lateral impact.
Quantification of biomechanical tolerance is essential
to describe the aspect of head injury in different accident
scenarios. There are two widely adapted methods available
in the literatures to enumerate the tolerance limit: One is
controlled laboratory experiments [33], and the other is
numerical computation using mathematical analogue [4–6].
Both the methods have their limitations. There are restric-
tions and ethical issues to conduct experiments with post-
mortem human surrogate (PMHS) specimen. On the other
hand, mathematical simulations have the unique ability to
Abstract The effect of head mass on its biomechanical
response during lateral impact to the head is investigated in
this computational study. The mass of the head of a state-
of-the-art validated finite element head model is altered by
±10 % from the base value of 4.7 kg. Numerical simula-
tions of lateral head impacts for 30 cases (representing 15
human cadaver experiments × 2 mass configurations) are
performed using the LS-DYNA solver at different veloci-
ties ranging from 2.4 to 6.5 m/s and three impacting con-
ditions representing different stiffness and shapes of the
contact/impact surfaces. Results are compared with the
original model using the baseline head mass, thus resulting
in a total of 45 simulations. Present findings show that the
head mass has greater influence for peak interaction forces
and the force has a greater dependency on stiffness of con-
tact surface than the shape. Mass variations have also influ-
ence on skull strain energy. Regardless of increase/decrease
in skull strain energy influenced by head mass variations
used in the computational study, the 50 % fracture toler-
ance limit was unaltered, which was 544 mJ. The present
study gives a better understanding of the mechanism of
temporo-parietal skull impact.
Keywords Parametric study · Temporo-parietal impact
experiments · Peak forces · Finite element model · Skull
fracture
* Caroline Deck
deck@unistra.fr
1
Université de Strasbourg ICube, UNISTRA-CNRS,
2 rue Boussingault, 67000 Strasbourg, France
2
Department of Neurosurgery, Medical College of Wisconsin,
9200 West Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53226, USA