Experimental Evidence for Sign Reversal of the Hall Coefficient in Three-Dimensional
Metamaterials
Christian Kern,
1,2
Muamer Kadic,
1,2
and Martin Wegener
1,2
1
Institute of Applied Physics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), 76128 Karlsruhe, Germany
2
Institute of Nanotechnology, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), 76021 Karlsruhe, Germany
(Received 18 July 2016; published 4 January 2017)
Effectively inverting the sign of material parameters is a striking possibility arising from the concept
of metamaterials. Here, we show that the electrical properties of a p-type semiconductor can be mimicked
by a metamaterial solely made of an n-type semiconductor. By fabricating and characterizing three-
dimensional simple-cubic microlattices composed of interlocked hollow semiconducting tori, we
demonstrate that sign and magnitude of the effective metamaterial Hall coefficient can be adjusted via
a tori separation parameter—in agreement with previous theoretical and numerical predictions.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.016601
The properties of composites or rationally designed
artificial materials called metamaterials are generally not
in between those of their constituents; i.e., “one gets out
more than one puts in” [1,2]. Unbounded behavior is
possible, too. Sign reversal of an effective material param-
eter with respect to the constituents is a particularly striking
case. The availability of positive and negative parameter
values largely enhances our ability to mold waves and
fluxes. Thus, sign reversals have contributed much to the
excitement in the field of metamaterials. In the dynamic
case, they are well known by now. Examples are the
magnetic permeability [3–5], the refractive index [4,6,7],
the mechanical compressibility [8,9], the mass density
[10–12], or both of the latter [13–16]. In all of these
examples, the sign inversion arises from some sort of
internal resonance. For frequencies above the correspond-
ing eigenfrequency, the response exhibits a 180-degree
phase shift, i.e., a reversal of sign. Clearly, this mechanism
does not work in the stationary limit.
Moreover, for passive media in the stationary limit, due
to the second law of thermodynamics, reversing the sign of
transport coefficients like the electric conductivity, the heat
conductivity, or the diffusivity is even fundamentally
impossible. The Hall coefficient is a notable exception.
It is directly connected to the off-diagonal elements of the
electric conductivity tensor in the presence of a static
magnetic field. In the simplest case, the Hall coefficient A
H
is equal to the inverse of the charge density, i.e., A
H
¼ ρ
−1
.
A few years ago, building upon earlier work [17–19], Marc
Briane and Graeme W. Milton predicted theoretically that
the sign of the isotropic Hall coefficient can be reversed in
chainmail-like three-dimensional metamaterials [20].
Notably, art inspired science: Chainmail artist Dylon
Whyte suggested to them the three-dimensional structure
[21]. Sign reversal of the Hall coefficient in metamaterials
is interesting because one can, for example, effectively
mimic p-doped silicon when having only n-doped silicon
available as a constituent. However, an experimental
validation of this mind-boggling prediction has not been
published so far.
In this Letter, we present experimental evidence for the
predicted sign inversion of the effective Hall coefficient in
chainmail-like metamaterials. We show that the sign as well
as the magnitude of the Hall coefficient can be determined
by a geometrical separation parameter while fixing the
FIG. 1. Blueprint for the three-dimensional chainmail-like
metamaterial discussed in this Letter. It is composed of a
simple-cubic lattice of hollow tori. a is the lattice constant, R
the torus radius, r the wire radius, t the film thickness, and d the
separation parameter. The latter can be positive or negative; the
depicted configuration corresponds to d< 0.
PRL 118, 016601 (2017)
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS
week ending
6 JANUARY 2017
0031-9007=17=118(1)=016601(5) 016601-1 © 2017 American Physical Society