Int. J Sup. Chain. Mgt Vol. 9, No. 4, August 2020
849
The Supply Chain Management of Islamic and
Conventional Banks; Evidence from Indonesian
Case
Imronudin
1
, Henry Dwi Wahyudi
2
1
Management Department, Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta
Abstract— The present study aims to examine the idea
of supply chain management in the financial institutions
like banks in the region of Indonesia. After the detailed
examination of existing literature current research
work has developed a model for the supply chain in
financial perspective with its physical implication as
well. This study use panel or pooled data taken from
annual report of Islamic and conventional banks in
Indonesia during 2012-2017 period and consist of 10
Islamic and 24 conventional banks. Pooled regression is
used to estimate the effect of bank-specific such as
profitability, growth, tangibility, earning volatility and
size on supply chain management. The finding of this
study shows that profitability and growth have positive
and significant effect on supply chain management,
while size and tangible asset have negative impact on it
of conventional banks. Earning volatility does not have
any influence on supply chain management both for
Islamic and conventional banks. In general, there is no
significant explanatory variables which have significant
influence on supply chain management of Islamic banks
except growth variable which have marginal impact on
supply chain management decision. In the future, this
research can be developed by using different measure
of earning volatility.
Keywords— Supply chain management, Supply Chain
Management, Islamic banks, Conventional Banks
1. Introduction
Islamic and conventional banks have the same
function as intermediary institutions channeling
funds from parties who have excess funds to those
who lack funds. However, both banks use different
modes in delivering their funds. Conventional
banks used interest as a basis in providing credit to
their customers. Since the interest is determined in
advance, conventional banks are relatively easy to
determine profit they will earn, namely spread or
the different between deposit and credit interest [1-
5].
Conversely, Islamic banks does not charge nor
provide any interest to their customers. Instead,
Islamic banks use profit and loss sharing mode of
finance in channeling their funds, particularly
murabahah and musharakah contracts [6]. Based on
this profit and loss sharing principles, their profit
depends on the profit of their customers and hence,
Islamic banks cannot estimate properly their profit as
conventional banks. Therefore, Islamic bank are more
risky that their counterpart. This condition will
influence on their supply chain management decision.
Supply chain management is a ratio between liabilities
and equity capital. The higher the liability the higher
fixed burden of the banks and then the riskier. Since
every source of capital have different cost of capital,
banks should determine ideal supply chain
management. Ideal supply chain management is the
ratio of debt and equity that can minimize cost of
capital which in turn improve form’s value.
The debt irrelevance proposition of [7] suggest that in
perfect market (i.e no asymmetric information, no
transaction cost, no taxes, no bankruptcy cost, and no
agency cost), no ideal supply chain management. In
other word, the choice of source of capital does not
have any impact on firm’s value. Thus, in perfect
market, the different types of capital is not relevant. In
reality, however, firms have to bear tax and hence
supply chain management choice is relevant because
of the fact that interest is a tax deductible expense and
generates a valuable tax shield [8]. Until recently,
topic concerning supply chain management is still
attractive for academicians to investigate. Current
research on supply chain management are many, for
instance, [9-12].
Although there are a lot of researches on supply chain
management, investigating supply chain management
of Islamic bank is still attractive because the present
of Islamic banks is quite new. Since Islamic bank is
relatively new business entity which have different
operation basis than that of conventional bank, this
study interested in comparing the supply chain
management decision of both Islamic and
conventional banks particularly in Indonesia.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows:
Section 2 describes the literature review and
hypothesis development. Section 3 presents data,
variables, and research methodology. Section 4
presents empirical results and discussion. Finally,
______________________________________________________________
International Journal of Supply Chain Management
IJSCM, ISSN: 2050-7399 (Online), 2051-3771 (Print)
Copyright © ExcelingTech Pub, UK (http://excelingtech.co.uk/)