Original article 21
Chronic outpatient management of asthmatics attending
the emergency department: a survey from a country with
low income
Lamia Ouanes-Besbes
a
, Jalel Knani
c
, Noureddine Nciri
a
, Fahmi Dachraoui
a
,
Semir Nouira
b
and Fekri Abroug
a
Purpose Little is known about compliance with
international guidelines of asthma management in
developing countries where some medications are
prohibitively expensive.
Methods A survey was conducted in asthmatic patients
attending the emergency department for acute asthma.
Asthma severity was evaluated and conformity of chronic
treatment with international guidelines was assessed.
Additional features of asthmatic education were also
evaluated.
Results A total of 127 consecutive patients (mean age
34 ± 14 years) answered the questionnaire. Mild asthma
was present in 19.7% patients, 56.7% had moderate
asthma and 23.6% had severe asthma. Of the 124 known
asthmatic patients, 33% had no treatment for chronic
asthma. In the remaining, treatment adhered to
international guidelines in 44% patients. The major
cause of treatment inadequacy was the lack of inhaled
corticosteroids (64%) or suboptimal dosage of
corticosteroids (13%). Conformity to guidelines according
to favorable or unfavorable economic conditions was 59%
and 33%, respectively (P = 0.036). Treating physicians
provided an ‘action plan’ for managing acute symptoms
to 19% patients. Forty percent of asthmatic patients
performed correctly the five components of metered dose
inhaler use.
Conclusion Our study reveals an important proportion of
non-treated asthmatic patients. In most asthmatic patients,
treatment did not conform with guidelines because of an
underutilization of corticosteroids, mainly because of
economic obstacles. European Journal of Emergency
Medicine 13:21–25
c
2006 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
European Journal of Emergency Medicine 2006, 13:21–25
Keywords: asthma, developing countries, emergency medicine, guidelines,
survey, therapeutics
a
Intensive Care Unit,
b
Emergency Department, Fatouma Bourguiba Hospital,
Monastir and
c
Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Tahar Sfar Hospital, Mahdia,
Tunisia.
Correspondence and requests for reprints to Fekri Abroug, MD, Intensive Care
Unit, CHU F. Bourguiba, 5000 Tunisia
Tel: + 21673460672; fax: + 21673460678; e-mail: f.abroug@rns.tn
Received 25 April 2005 Accepted 27 September 2005
Introduction
Asthma is a chronic affection with a prevalence of almost
15 million people in the United States [1,2]. More than
12 billion dollars is spent on asthma care each year, 20% of
which is dedicated to hospitalization [3–6]. USA
expenditure on asthma care represents no less than 34%
of the gross national product of a country like Tunisia in
2001, of which only 2.2% is dedicated to the health
budget (www.tunisie.com/economie). In order to improve
asthma management, several programs, consensus and
expert recommendations were set out principally by
scientific societies and authorities from the developed
countries [7–11]. These guidelines recommend regular
prophylactic medication to prevent chronic symptoms.
They stress the importance of a step-by-step approach of
asthma treatment, an approach that should include
inhaled corticosteroids in moderate to severe asthma.
All these recommendations also emphasize the impor-
tance of both patient’s education and self-management of
symptoms. The guidelines also recommend that all
patients must be provided with an action plan that must
be implemented each time an asthma attack occurs.
These guidelines are intended for global application in
both rich and developing countries. Yet, these guidelines
were developed on the main basis of their efficacy from
an evidence-based stand point and less credit was paid to
the medication costs, especially for inhaled corticoster-
oids that are not easily affordable in developing countries.
The lack of alternatives for these countries might
represent a cause of suboptimal quality of care although
information is lacking about the extent to which these
guidelines are implemented in less developed countries
in which economic impediment might limit the access to
essential medications like inhaled steroids, a study
conducted through a questionnaire addressed to expatri-
ate doctors practicing in developing countries suggested a
less than optimal management of asthmatic patients in
these countries because drugs are unavailable or are
prohibitively expensive [12]. This is a matter of
0969-9546 c 2006 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.