T T UMMA — M R?
575
Blackwell Publishing, Ltd. Oxford, UK MUWO The Muslim World 0027-4909 © 2005 Hartford Seminary October 2005 95 4 ORIGINAL ARTICLE
The Transnational Umma Myth or Reality The Muslim World Volume 95 October 2005
The Transnational Umma
— Myth or Reality?
Examples from the Western
Diasporas
Garbi Schmidt
Danish National Institute of Social Research
Copenhagen, Denmark
The Umma as Vision and Practice
I
n the mid-1990s, a frequent site for my ongoing research of Muslims in
Chicago was a small student room at the University of De Paul. At most
other campuses in the city Muslims simply organized as “MSAs” — Muslim
Student Associations — but not at De Paul. Four capital letters cut from bright
colored paper and forming the word “UMMA” hung at the door. Members
knew that UMMA was an acronym for “United Muslims Moving Ahead,” and
most were probably also familiar with another and more widely spread
implication of the word: The community of believers in Islam.
The umma concept has long historical, theological and theoretical
implications. It is a central component in Friday prayers and in Islamic studies
literature — or a part of every student of Islam’s academic jargon. In many
ways the scholarly use of the umma concept is a means by which we frame a
particular niche of research and make it distinguishable from others. In this
article I want to discuss the concept’s implications in a current, transnational
setting, as a means of capturing a possible fragment of transnational religious
visions and practices. What intrigues me is the apparent strong consensus
between believers, researchers and even politicians within secular Westerns
nation states that the umma in today’s world is truly transnational. Although
the idea is enchanting, it needs further scrutiny, based on the analysis of
empirical data. Do young American Muslims, for example, network with
Muslims in other Western settings as a result of shared religious convictions,
and, if so, what is the fabric of such networks?