415
Clinical Neuropsychiatry (2017) 14, 6, 415-423
415
ASSESSING SITUATIONAL DYSPHORIA IN BORDERLINE PATIENTS: DEVELOPMENT AND
PRELIMINARY VALIDATION OF THE SITUATIONAL DYSPHORIA SCALE (SITDS)
Alessandra D’Agostino, Antonella Aportone, Mario Rossi Monti, Vladan Starcevic
Abstract
Objective: According to recent phenomenological literature, dysphoria is the psychopathological core of borderline
personality disorder (BPD). It is a complex emotional state that consists of persistent tension, irritability, discontent and
unhappiness, which is diffcult to modulate and is associated with impulsivity. Under certain circumstances, this basic
“kind” of dysphoria (“background dysphoria”) can be experienced differently, as “situational dysphoria”. The latter is
a sense of pressure, an urge to act and a feeling of quasi-explosion that is mostly related to interpersonal triggers. The
aim of this study was to present the process of developing a questionnaire for measuring situational dysphoria in BPD
(the Situational Dysphoria Scale, SITDS) and test its psychometric properties.
Method: The sample consisted of 105 borderline patients recruited from adult psychiatric outpatient services and
residential inpatient communities. The SITDS was developed over several stages, with the initial version consisting
of 58 items. In order to test convergent and discriminant validity, the SITDS was administered with four self-report
instruments (Nepean Dysphoria Scale, Cynical Distrust Scale, Inventory of Interpersonal Problems-47 and Empathy
Quotient) and one semi-structured interview (Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index-IV).
Results: The fnal version of SITDS, consisting of 24 items, was derived after conducting two factor analyses,
a hierarchical cluster analysis and further refnement of the scale. It is divided into three clusters (Personal Events,
Interpersonal Events and Environmental Events) and rated on three subscales (Internal Pressure, Urge to Act and Quasi-
Explosion). This version of the SITDS demonstrated excellent internal consistency (Cronbach’s alpha value = .91) and
a solid degree of convergent and discriminant validity.
Conclusions: The study provides preliminary support for use of the SITDS in BPD. Further studies of psychometric
properties of the SITDS are needed to support it as a tool for routine clinical practice.
Key words: dysphoria, situational dysphoria, psychometric properties, borderline personality disorder
Declaration of interest: none
Alessandra D’Agostino
1
, Antonella Aportone
1
, Mario Rossi Monti
1
, Vladan Starcevic
2
1
Borderline & Body Lab, Department of Humanistic Studies, University of Urbino, Italy.
2
Discipline of Psychiatry, Sydney Medical School – Nepean, University of Sydney, Australia.
Corresponding author
Alessandra D’Agostino, Borderline & Body Lab, Department of Humanistic Studies, University of Urbino, Italy,
via Saff, 15, 61029, Urbino (PU), Italy. E-mail: ales.dagostino@gmail.com.
Introduction
Dysphoria is as an emotional state that is the
psychopathological core of borderline personality
disorder (BPD) (Rossi Monti 2012, Stanghellini and
Rosfort 2013, Rossi Monti and D’Agostino 2014).
It consists of a combination of tension, irritability,
discontent and unhappiness that persists and is associated
with a growing impulsivity (Starcevic 2007). This
emotional constellation is a centrifugal force that can
fragment the borderline person’s representations of
oneself and of others, inducing a painful experience of
incoherence and inner emptiness, a feeling of uncertainty
and inauthenticity in relationships, along with a sense
of futility and inanity of the whole life (Stanghellini
and Rosfort 2013). Considering that this emotional
experience is so fundamental for BPD, it is referred to as
“background dysphoria”.
The characteristics of dysphoria change in certain
circumstances, with the predominant sense of pressure,
an urge to act and experience of a quasi-explosion. This
is usually related to the environmental and interpersonal
context, represents the here-and-now experience of
individuals with BPD (Rossi Monti and D’Agostino in
press) and is referred to as “situational dysphoria”. It
is often experienced as impatience and intolerance that
can lead to outbursts of anger and violent behaviour.
In addition, situational dysphoria is characterised by a
feeling of being “on edge” and heightened anxiety and
vigilance. Considering that situational dysphoria occurs in
response to situational triggers, it represents a temporary,
but repetitive experience of borderline patients.
Taking into account these perspectives, background
dysphoria and situational dysphoria are very important
for understanding both the basic and transient experience
of borderline patients. However, assessing adequately
these two forms of dysphoria has been diffcult. In fact,
while a self-report instrument for background dysphoria
already exists (Nepean Dysphoria Scale; Berle and
Starcevic 2012) and has been translated and validated
into Italian language (D’Agostino et al. 2016), a scale
for situational dysphoria did not exist until recently.
This article aims to explain the development of a
questionnaire for assessment of situational dysphoria
in BPD (the Situational Dysphoria Scale) and test its
psychometric properties.
Submitted June 2017, Accepted OctOber 2017
© 2017 Giovanni Fioriti Editore s.r.l.