Abstract - The primary object of this research is to
explain and demonstrate the complex structure that links
each variable within the dairy milk supply chain in
Indonesia through the causal loop diagram (CLD). Referring
to the structure of the National Model developed by
Forrester (1989), there were six CLDs which belong to six
sub-systems used to describe the relationship between
variables in the dairy supply chain. The first CLD belong to
population and consumption sub-system. The second until
sixth CLD belong to milk production sub-system, dairy
cattle sub-system, dairy cattle population sub-system, dairy
farmer's income sub-system, and government sub-system.
According to CLD, there are minimal one important drivers
in each sub-system. The findings in this paper put forward
some important issues that require for running the full
simulation of some proposed scenarios.
Keywords – causal loop diagram, dairy supply chain,
National Model, six sub-system
I. INTRODUCTION
Supply chain management (SCM) is a network of
connected and interdependent organizations working
together, mutually and cooperatively, to control, manage
and improve the flow of material and information from
suppliers to end users [1]. The most important problem in
SCM is coping with high uncertainty because of internal
and external factors. It can change the behavior of the
supply chain [2] and then, have the significant impact on
the performance of the supply chain. In this context of the
uncertain environment, this research interested in studying
the behavior of the food supply chain, specifically the
behavior of the dairy milk supply chain. The source of
uncertainty in the dairy milk supply chain can be seen
from four stages in the dairy value chain structure, namely
input suppliers, milk production, processing, and
marketing. Input suppliers represent supplies to farmers
including feed, veterinary services, etc. Milk production
means the operators who produce milk, and this includes
dairy farmers, corporate farmers, and smallholders.
Processing refers to companies which process the
delivered milk. The forms of companies are co-operatives,
multinational/ national companies, and small dairy
companies. Marketing expresses the way dairy products
are sold, including export, supermarkets, small retailers,
etc. [3]. Related to the four stages in dairy value chain
structure as the source of uncertainty, In Indonesia, milk
production is dominated by dairy farmers which are
members of local dairy cooperatives. The uncertainty of
good quantity and quality supply frequently arise because
the action conducted by dairy farmers usually not the
same as those of the local dairy cooperative wanted. This
problem becomes more complicated since there is no
formal contract arrangement between dairy farmers and
local cooperatives to inhibit each of party acting in their
own interest or to inhibit the opportunistic behaviors of
each of party in a transaction. The farmers are
independent milk producers. Although the local
cooperatives give some supplies to farmers (such as feed,
veterinary services, etc.), the farmers have full
responsibility for running out of the dairy farms day-to-
day. The farmers can choose anything connected to their
businesses by themselves. This condition makes, on the
one hand, the dairy farmers have a good bargaining power
and, on the other, the cooperative difficult to control the
business and to predict and manage the certain quantity
and quality of the supply flow. The dairy cooperative is
repeatedly not capable to get the certain quality of fresh
milk as required by the processor or the national standard
[4], [5], [6], [7]. As the milk processor difficult to get
quantity and quality of fresh milk as required, they will
import.
This research has chosen dairy milk supply as an
object for studying the behavior of supply chain in the
context of uncertainty, because its performance has
received a great deal of attention in the last decade, due to
issues related to food self-sufficiency. In this case, the
uncertainty can hurt the performance of dairy milk supply
chain. According to the Indonesian Coordinating Ministry
of Economy, there are several objectives should be
achieved by dairy milk in Indonesia. Those objectives can
be seen in the Road Map of Indonesian Dairy 2015 –
2025. According to the roadmap, the national milk
production should reach 2.75 million tons in 2020 and
5.32 milk tons in 2025. Besides, dairy cattle should reach
1.3 million heads in 2020 and 1.7 million heads in 2025.
In 2020, the dairy cattle must be able to produce an
average of 13.11 liters of milk per day and an average of
19.67 liters per day in 2025 [8], [9]. So, in this case, the
studying of the behavior of the dairy milk supply chain is
needed to formulate the scenario to achieve the target
established by the Government of Indonesia.
So, in order to predict the behavior of dairy supply
chain in the context of uncertainty, the primary object of
this research is to explain and demonstrate the complex
structure and the various feedback loops that link each
variable within dairy milk supply chain through system
dynamics methodology. Systems Dynamics (SD),
initially recognized as ‘industrial dynamics', is a
Modeling the Causal Relationship Among Variables that Influencing the
Capability of Dairy Supply Chain in Indonesia
A. Susanty
1
, N. B. Puspitasari
1
, A. Bakhtiar
1
, N. Susanto
1
, D. Kurnia
1
1
Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Diponegoro, Semarang, Indonesia
(ariessusanty@gmail.com; niabudipuspitasari@gmail.com, arfanbakhtiar@googlemail.com)
.
27 978-1-5386-6786-6/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE