Research Paper
Human excreta: a resource or a taboo? Assessing the
socio-cultural barriers, acceptability, and reuse of human
excreta as a resource in Kakul Village District Abbottabad,
Northwestern Pakistan
Abda Khalid
ABSTRACT
Sustainable reuse of human excreta in socially and religiously conservative societies is extremely
difficult. People’s perceptions and acceptability regarding the reuse of human excreta is mainly
linked to their culture. In addition, certain societies regard the cultural and social barriers more than
the religious barriers. The aim of this study is to understand the perceptions of people about the
reuse of human excreta for agricultural purposes. Qualitative research methods were used for data
collection. Farmers in the village recognized the importance and economic benefit of reusing human
excreta. They accepted the reuse of human excreta on their farms only if they were supplied with a
treatment facility. Contrary to the farmers, the local community showed reluctance in reusing human
excreta while recognizing the nutritional value of it. It was therefore concluded that the main barrier
in sustainable and safe re-use of human excreta lies in socio-cultural and religious foundations of
traditional societies like Kakul village in Abbottabad District.
Abda Khalid
COMSTATS Institute of Information Technology,
Abbottabad,
Pakistan
E-mail: abda@ciit.net.pk
Key words | accessibility, feces, human excreta, recycling, rural, urine
INTRODUCTION
Communities round the globe identify themselves with bio-
regions and are actively re-localizing their material
resources. The focus of the localized issue revolves mostly
around food security. However, the focus as predicted by
researchers will soon shift to the other end of the nutrient
cycle, i.e. recycling of human waste (Murtaza et al. ).
Many researchers working on recycling of human waste
argued that the blind flushing of excreta is equal to flushing
of our personal responsibility. Therefore, in Pakistan too,
excreta disposal is very complicated and is linked with var-
ious issues. The two major aspects of excreta mishandling
are, first, the excreta which is not disposed of properly gets
mixed with underground drinking water aquifer, second,
the multiple, socio-cultural and religious taboos related to
recycling and disposing of excreta (Murtaza et al. ).
Similarly in the case of Pakistan, to address the possi-
bility of the reuse of human excreta it is mandatory to
probe deeper and carefully into socio-cultural barriers. The
existing body of literature and critical analyses of the insti-
tutional setup in the country shows that there are no
specific rules and regulations which address the scientific
incorporation of recycled human excreta in the fields, nor
is there any concept of ecological sanitation or decentra-
lized systems. The sanitation ladder stops at the
Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) approach, which
means that the harmful effects of sanitation are not yet
71 Research Paper © IWA Publishing 2018 Journal of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene for Development | 08.1 | 2018
doi: 10.2166/washdev.2017.019
Downloaded from http://iwaponline.com/washdev/article-pdf/8/1/71/512561/washdev0080071.pdf
by guest
on 30 July 2022