83
For more than a century the consensus of eminent Protestant and Eastern
Orthodox historians of dogma was that deifcation is a distinctively Eastern
doctrine incompatible with the Western theological tradition. For the
Reformation traditions, deifcation was said to be especially precluded by
total depravity, predestination, and justifcation by faith alone. These claims
habituated generations of scholars to presume soteriologies of deifcation
are alien to the Protestant tradition. From the beginning, however, this
commonplace was apologetic propaganda presented in the guise of critical
scholarship.
1
It fails for the simple reason that examination of the primary
sources of the Protestant tradition shows it to be false. Scholars have increas-
ingly recognized this in recent years, but the claim is not new. Writing in the
1960s, already Jaroslav Pelikan observed, “Western theology and spirituality
spoke in such language also; so, for that matter, did the Reformers and other
Protestant divines.”
2
The thesis of this chapter is simple. The patristic doctrine of deifcation
found in such writers as Irenaeus, Athanasius, Cyril of Alexandria, and
Augustine is a biblical doctrine of the universal church affrmed by the
Reformers and their immediate heirs. It is neither an exotic import nor inva-
sive species in the garden of Reformed theology. Like Nicene Trinitarianism,
creatio ex nihilo, and the canon of the New Testament, it is a constitutive part
of the catholic inheritance which the Reformers sought to uphold and defend.
Early Reformed theologians affrmed that it is appropriate to describe the
goal or telos of salvation in terms of deifcation. Be that as it may, deifcation
as a concise and appropriately evocative description of the gospel’s end and
our highest good receded into the background. Christians in the Reformed
Chapter 4
The Gospel’s End and
Our Highest Good
Deification in the Reformed Tradition
Carl Mosser
Copyright © 2021. Fortress Academic. All rights reserved.
From: Jared Ortiz, ed., With All the Fullness of God: Deification in Christian
Tradition (Lexington Books/Fortress Academic, 2021), 83-109.