Received: 13 August 2001
Accepted: 26 June 2002
Published online: 10 August 2002
© Springer-Verlag 2002
Abstract Objective: Laryngeal ede-
ma secondary to endotracheal intu-
bation may require early re-intuba-
tion. Prior to extubation the absence
of leak around an endotracheal tube
may predict laryngeal edema after
extubation. We evaluated the useful-
ness of a quantitative assessment of
such a leak to identify the patients
who will require early re-intubation
for laryngeal edema. Methods: This
prospective study included 76 pa-
tients with endotracheal intubation
for more than 12 h. The leak, in per-
cent, was defined as the difference
between expired tidal volume mea-
sured just before extubation, in vol-
ume-controlled mode, with the cuff
inflated and then deflated. The best
cut-off value to predict the need for
re-intubation for significant laryn-
geal edema was determined and the
patients were divided into two
groups, according to this cut-off val-
ue. Results: Eight of the 76 patients
(11%) needed re-intubation for la-
ryngeal edema. Patients requiring re-
intubation had a smaller leak than
the other patients [9 (3–18) vs 35
(13–53)%, p<0.01]. The best cut-off
value for gas leak was 15.5%. The
high leak group included 51 patients,
of whom only two patients (3%) re-
quired re-intubation. The low leak
group included 25 patients, among
whom six patients (24%) required
re-intubation (p<0.01). The sensitivi-
ty of this test was 75%, the specifici-
ty 72.1%, the positive predictive val-
ue 25%, the negative predictive val-
ue 96.1% and the percent of correct
classification 72.4%. Conclusions: A
gas leak around the endotracheal
tube greater than 15.5% can be used
as a screening test to limit the risk of
re-intubation for laryngeal edema.
Keywords Cuff leak test ·
Laryngeal edema · Endotracheal
intubation · Mechanical ventilation ·
Extubation failure · Stridor
Intensive Care Med (2002) 28:1267–1272
DOI 10.1007/s00134-002-1422-3 ORIGINAL
Yann De Bast
Daniel De Backer
Jean-Jacques Moraine
Muriel Lemaire
Cécile Vandenborght
Jean-Louis Vincent
The cuff leak test to predict failure
of tracheal extubation for laryngeal edema
Introduction
Endotracheal intubation may generate local complica-
tions, including mechanical lesions like friction, com-
pressions between the tube and the anatomic structures
[1], and also biochemical reactions at the interaction be-
tween the plastic or silicone tube material and the upper
airway mucosa. Even though their incidence has de-
creased with the use of far more flexible polyvinyl chlo-
ride tubes generating less pressure on the anatomical
structures and high volume low pressure cuffs inducing
fewer mucosal lesions [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6], these complica-
tions remain frequent. Laryngeal edema manifests itself
by respiratory distress and inspiratory whistling called
“stridor”. Such edema formation can develop as early as
6 h after intubation [7], so that prolonged intubation is
not a prerequisite to its development [8, 9]. By decreas-
ing the upper respiratory tract diameter, laryngeal edema
increases airway resistance and, consequently, the respi-
ratory work. When edema is present, re-intubation may
be required if the patient is not able to sustain the in-
crease in respiratory work. The development of laryngeal
Y. De Bast · D. De Backer · J.-J. Moraine
M. Lemaire · C. Vandenborght
J.-L. Vincent (
✉
)
Department of Intensive Care,
Erasme University Hospital,
Free University of Brussels,
808 route de Lennick, 1070 Brussels,
Belgium
e-mail: jlvincen@ulb.ac.be
Tel.: +32-2-5553380
Fax: +32-2-5554555