366 © IWA Publishing 2013 Water Science & Technoiogy | 67.2 | 2013
Fate of pathogen indicators in a domestic biend of food
waste and wastewater through a two-stage anaerobic
digestion system
B. D. Rounsefell, C. A. O'Sullivan, N. Chinivasagam, D. Batstone
and W. P. Clarke
ABSTRACT
Anaerobic digestion is a viabie on-site treatment technoiogy for rich organic waste streams such as
food waste and biaci<water. In contrast to iarge-scale municipal wastewater treatment piants which are
typicaiiy located away from the community, the effiuent from any type of on-site system is a potential
pathogenic hazard because of the intimacy of the system to the community. The native concentrations
of tiie pathogen indicators Escherichia coll, Closthdium perfringens and somatic coiiphage were
traci<ed for 30 days under stable operation (organic loading rate (OLR) = 1.8 kgCOD m^^ day~\ methane
yield = 52% on a chemicai oxygen demand (COD) basis) of a two-stage laboratory-scale digester treating
a mixture of food waste and blaci<water. £ coli numbers were reduced by a factor of 10'^" in the
thermophiiic stage, from ^o'•^^°3 to ^o^^'^*°'' cfu 100 mL~\ but regenerated by a factor of 10" in the
mesophilic stage. Neither the thermophiiic nor mesophilic stages had any significant impact on
C. perfringens concentrations. Coiiphage concentrations were reduced by a factor of lO''" across the
two stages. The study shows that anaerobic digestion oniy reduces pathogen counts marginally but that
counts in effiuent samples could be readiiy reduced to below detection iimits by filtration through a
0.22 Mm membrane, to investigate membrane filtration as a possible sanitation technique.
Key words | anaerobic digestion, blackwater, food waste, pathogen
B. D. Rounsefell
C. A, O'Sullivan
W. p. Clarke (corresponding author)
Schools of Civil and Chemical Engineering,
The University of Queensland,
Brisbane, 4072, Qld.
Australia
E-mail: william.clarke@uq.ed.au
N. Chinivasagam
Animal Research Institute,
Queensland Primary industries and Fisheries,
Yeerongpilly, 4105, Qld,
Australia
D. Batstone
Advanced Water Management Centre,
The University of Queensland.
Brisbane, 4072, Qld,
Australia
C. A. O'Sullivan
Current address: Plant Industry,
CSIRQ, Underwood Ave,
Floreat, 6014, WA,
Australia
INTRODUCTION
The putrescible waste produced by households is proble-
matic as a source of odour and an attractant for vermin.
While this material is often beneficially composted on prop-
erties with gardens, on-site treatment is generally not
considered for high density residences. However, waste dis-
posal levies and the high demand for renewable energy
provides incentive for households and residential clusters
such as apartment blocks to consider on-site anaerobic
digestion of rich organic waste streams such as food waste.
Touet wastewater (blackwater) can also be digested
although the organic content of blacl<water is low compared
vwth solid organic waste at typical domestic production rates
(Verstraete & Vandevivere 1999). However, the utility of an
on-site anaerobic digestion system is enhanced if blacliwater
can also be treated by the system, obviating the need for a
dedicated on-site wastewater treatment system. The sanitation
capacity of a digester under this circumstance is of interest.
Anaerobic treatment has been shown to have the poten-
tial to perform a degree of disinfection because the low pH
and high temperature conditions that are suitable for hydro-
lytic fermentative organisms are generally not viable for
most pathogens (Olsen & Larsen 1987; Kunte et al. 1998).
These conditions are readily achieved in the first stage of a
two-stage digestion process where high temperatures can
be maintained using only a portion of the produced
biogas. In contrast, maintaining high temperatures in
aerobic systems is reliant on imported energy where the
heat energy demand would also be prohibitive due to the
amount of agitation and sparging needed to maintain
aerobic conditions. Olsen & Larsen (1987) found destruction
times for Escherichia coli were of the order of hours at 53 C
compared with days at 35 °C for animal slurry wastes being
treated using anaerobic digestion. Nielsen & Petersen (2000)
compared the effect that full-scale mesophilic and
doi: 10.2166/wst.2012.573