THE QUALITY-CONSTRAINED SCHEDULING PROBLEM IN
PLASTICS COMPOUNDING
Abdunnaser Younes,* Ali Elkamel, Michelle Leung, Costas Tzoganakis and Ali Lohi
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada
Interest is increasing in plastic compounding plants that offer tailor-made resins. Such plants produce a wide range of products in small quantities
and with frequent changeovers. The underlying scheduling problem has been extensively researched; however, the concept of incorporating
qualities of the finished product in the problem of plastics compounding has not been considered.
We express product qualities as an additional problem constraint so that the production schedule ensures product quality. The additional
constraint makes this mixed integer nonlinear program (MINLP) problem more difficult to solve. Several case studies are solved to illustrate the
utility of the proposed approach.
Experiments demonstrated that qualities of the finished product can be ensured a priori if the appropriate relations are developed and inte-
grated in the optimisation model. As well, this paper provides insight into the economic aspects of the scheduling problem under consideration.
Experiments showed that none of the cost components (operation, raw material, inventory, penalty or utilities) can alone play the role of the
optimisation criterion.
Keywords: scheduling, plastics compounding, quality constraints, opportunity cost
INTRODUCTION
P
roduction scheduling is a common problem that occurs in
multi-product manufacturing facilities where a wide range
of products are produced in small quantities, resulting in
frequent changeovers.
Customarily, the scheduling of batch and semi-continues pro-
cesses is treated from either a multi-product or multi-purpose
perspective (Elkamel, 1993). In multi-product plants, the pro-
cessing units are arranged a priori and the products undergo the
same sequence of operations. In multipurpose plants, the plant is
configurable and hence different products can undergo different
operation sequences.
Several formulation and solution procedures have been pro-
posed for the scheduling of batch and semi-continuous processes.
We will not attempt to review the vast literature; we only cite
a few mathematical programming approaches. The MILP formu-
lation presented by Sahinidis and Grossmann (1991) leads to
tighter linear programming relaxation. However, the formulation
is restricted to special cases only. Tsirnkis and Reklaitis (1993a, b)
presented a search strategy to partition the problem domain. The-
oretically, the strategy leads to exact solutions when the fineness
of the partitions approaches zero. However, since the number of
partitions increases as well, the computation time becomes pro-
hibitively large with very fine partitions. Kondili et al. (1993)
presented a general framework tackling scheduling problems in
multi-product or multi-purpose batch chemical plants. They pro-
posed different schemes to improve the performance of the branch
and bound technique in MILP. Tsirnkis et al., (1993) proposed an
efficient two-level decomposition strategy for the MILP problem
in multi-purpose batch chemical plants with resource constraints.
In this paper, we are concerned with a plastics compounding
plant that offers tailor-made resins. This kind of scheduling prob-
lem has already been studied in the past. Schulz et al. (1998)
presented two different mathematical formulations, a continuous
time representation model and a fixed-grid model, to schedule a
multi-product polymer batch plant. The polymerisation process
that they had studied was a combination of serial and parallel
processes. Wang et al. (2000) solved a similar problem using
an augmented genetic algorithm. Castro et al. (2002) addressed
∗
Author to whom correspondence may be addressed.
E-mail address: ayounes@uwaterloo.ca
Can. J. Chem. Eng. 9999:1–15, 2012
©
2012 Canadian Society for Chemical Engineering
DOI 10.1002/cjce.21739
Published online in Wiley Online Library
(wileyonlinelibrary.com).
| VOLUME 9999, 2012 | | THE CANADIAN JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING | 1 |