Second Language Research
1–26
© The Author(s) 2017
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0267658316684905
journals.sagepub.com/home/slr
second
language
research
L1 English / L2 Spanish:
Orthography–phonology
activation without contrasts
Christine Shea
University of Iowa, USA
Abstract
We consider how orthography activates sounds that are in a noncontrastive relationship
in the second language (L2) and for which only one variant exists in the first language (L1).
Participants were L1 English / L2 Spanish and native Spanish listeners. Intervocalically, Spanish
graphemes ‘b d g’ correspond phonetically to stops and approximants (e.g. lobo ‘wolf’, lo[β]o),
and in English they correspond only to stops. In Experiment 1, native and L2 Spanish listeners
completed cross-modal (written–auditory) and within modal (auditory) priming tasks. Prime-
target pairs were counterbalanced for phonetic variant. The results for L2 listeners in the
cross-modal condition showed a significant interaction between variant and mode. Experiment
2 used long-term repetition priming to tap into longer-term representations and test whether
L1 orthography is activated even when it is not strictly necessary to complete the task. Results
for L2 speakers showed priming by both phonetic variants while for native listeners, only
approximants showed a priming effect.
Keywords
adult second language acquisition, cross-modal priming, orthography, phonology, Spanish
I Introduction
There is considerable evidence that learning to read restructures phonological represen-
tations, strongly influenced by the close connections between orthography and phonol-
ogy (Castles et al., 2011). Literate individuals have been shown to demonstrate sharper
categorical perception boundaries than nonliterate individuals (Serniclaes et al., 2005),
and literacy development (even in adulthood) has been shown to refine cortical organiza-
tion (Dehaene et al., 2010). In children, phonological awareness improves in tandem
Corresponding author:
Christine Shea, Department of Spanish and Portuguese, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA
Email: christine-shea@uiowa.edu
684905SLR 0 0 10.1177/0267658316684905Second Language ResearchShea
research-article 2017
Original Article