PHYSICAL REVIEW B 94, 035411 (2016)
Current-induced phonon renormalization in molecular junctions
Meilin Bai,
1, 2
Clotilde S. Cucinotta,
2 , *
Zhuoling Jiang,
1
Hao Wang,
1
Yongfeng Wang,
1, 3
Ivan Rungger,
2, 4
Stefano Sanvito,
2 , *
and Shimin Hou
1, 3 , *
1
Key Laboratory for the Physics and Chemistry of Nanodevices, Department of Electronics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
2
School of Physics, Advanced Materials and Bioengineering Research Centre (AMBER) and Centre for Research on Adaptive Nanostructures
and Nanodevices (CRANN) Institute, Trinity College, Dublin 2, Ireland
3
Beida Information Research (BIR), Tianjin 300457, China
4
Materials Division, National Physical Laboratory, Teddington, TW11 0LW, United Kingdom
(Received 14 March 2016; revised manuscript received 17 June 2016; published 8 July 2016)
We explain how the electrical current flow in a molecular junction can modify the vibrational spectrum
of the molecule by renormalizing its normal modes of oscillations. This is demonstrated with first-principles
self-consistent transport theory, where the current-induced forces are evaluated from the expectation value of the
ionic momentum operator. We explore here the case of H
2
sandwiched between two Au electrodes and show that
the current produces stiffening of the transverse translational and rotational modes and softening of the stretching
modes along the current direction. Such behavior is understood in terms of charge redistribution, potential drop,
and elasticity changes as a function of the current.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.94.035411
I. INTRODUCTION
Current-induced forces are at the origin of a rich variety
of effects, including vibrations and rotations, as well as mass
and energy flow at interfaces [1]. These forces, developing
in the presence of a current, underpin electromigration, a
phenomenon arising from the transfer of momentum from the
conduction electrons to the ions. They can induce structural
transformation in nanosystems and transfer energy to phonons,
in addition of being the ultimate cause of Joule heating [2].
When the electron current density is large enough, current-
induced forces can control redox reactions at electrode surfaces
and affect the functionality and stability of nanodevices,
molecular motors, and switches [3–8]. As a consequence, gain-
ing insight into the microscopic mechanisms and achieving
control of current-induced forces in nanojunctions will pave
the way for key advances in interface chemistry, molecular
electronics, and in memory and logic applications.
Molecular electronic devices, consisting of a single or a
few molecules bridging two electrodes, have been thoroughly
studied [9,10]. In designing robust molecular devices, it is
crucial to have information on the status of the molecule in
current-carrying conditions, since the applied bias and the
current-induced forces may affect the chemical bonds both
at the molecule-electrode interfaces and within the molecule
itself. Molecular vibrations are directly related to the molecule
geometry and inter/intramolecular bonds. Hence, vibrational
spectroscopy methods, such as inelastic electron tunneling,
infrared, and Raman, have been widely employed to investigate
the conduction mechanism and the stability of molecular
devices [11–19]. There is also some experimental evidence that
the current can modify the vibrational modes of the molecule
in a junction [17–19]. For example, the vibrational frequencies
of a single C
60
sandwiched between two Au electrodes appear
to be systematically lowered by the applied bias voltage, indi-
cating that the C-C bonds may be weakened by the current [19].
*
Corresponding authors: cucinotc@tcd.ie; SANVITOS@tcd.ie;
smhou@pku.edu.cn
Although experiments may sometimes achieve atomic res-
olution [20,21], most of them can only measure macroscopic
averaged quantities, meaning that the details of the micro-
scopic processes occurring in a nanojunction often remain a
matter of conjecture. This implies that computer simulations,
which have the power to resolve processes atom by atom,
are essential to magnify our view on these phenomena.
One way to investigate how a current density perturbs the
phonons of a biased system was proposed by L¨ u et al. [8].
A semiclassical generalized Langevin equation obtained from
path integrals was employed together with parameters obtained
from density functional theory (DFT). This approach is based
on a perturbative expansion of an electron effective action
[22] over the electron-phonon interaction matrix. Using this
approach, the impact of the different forces—random forces
describing Joule heating, current-induced forces including
nonconservative wind forces, dissipative frictional forces, and
the effective Lorentz-type force due to the Berry phase of
the nonequilibrium electrons—was compared for a graphene
nanoconstriction carrying high current [23]. The authors
observed a strongly nonlinear current-induced heating and a
breakdown of the harmonic approximation when the Fermi
level was tuned close to a resonance in the electronic structure
of the nanoconstriction, caused by the presence of negatively
damped phonons.
Here, we take an alternative approach and describe current-
induced forces within the Born-Oppenheimer approximation.
Since we are dealing with a nonequilibrium state where the
energy may not be conserved [1], we follow the derivation
of Di Ventra [24] and compute current-induced forces in
a general way from the expectation value of the ionic
momentum operator [25]. Importantly, in the presence of a
stationary current, charge redistribution occurs, causing atomic
rearrangements and modifying the instantaneous Hamiltonian.
As a consequence, the vibrational spectrum changes. We
account for such phenomena by calculating the electron
density with the nonequilibrium Green’s function formalism
(NEGF) combined with DFT. The density is then used
to self-consistently evaluate the effective nonequilibrium
2469-9950/2016/94(3)/035411(7) 035411-1 ©2016 American Physical Society