106 ACI Structural Journal/January-February 2009
ACI Structural Journal, V. 106, No. 1, January-February 2009.
MS No. S-2007-252.R2 received January 4, 2008, and reviewed under Institute
publication policies. Copyright © 2009, American Concrete Institute. All rights reserved,
including the making of copies unless permission is obtained from the copyright proprietors.
Pertinent discussion including author’s closure, if any, will be published in the November-
December 2009 ACI Structural Journal if the discussion is received by July 1, 2009.
ACI STRUCTURAL JOURNAL TECHNICAL PAPER
The presented research is part of a wider research project
involving the study of the dynamic behavior under extreme loads of
the Tenza Bridge, a concrete arch bridge located in southern Italy.
The dynamic behavior of the concrete of the bridge under tensile
loads is herein investigated. Several dynamic tensile tests under
different strain rates were performed on concrete specimens at the
DynaMat laboratory of the University of Applied Sciences of
Southern Switzerland using modified Hopkinson bars. The results
were then processed in terms of strength dynamic increase
factor-strain rate relationships. These are fundamental to assess
constitutive laws of concrete to be implemented in analytical
models of the bridge under dynamic loads. The results are
compared with existing analytical formulations that attempt to
predict the dynamic tensile strength of concrete. The comparisons
show that, even though tested concrete was taken from an existing
structure, the relationships found in the literature accurately
describe its tensile dynamic behavior.
Keywords: dynamic behavior; loads; strain; tensile strength.
INTRODUCTION
Nowadays, structural design of some critical infrastructures
has to allow for events such as blasts, impacts, or strong
earthquakes, which force such structures to withstand severe
dynamic load conditions, characterized by high intensity and
short duration. Therefore, dynamic properties of materials
play a fundamental role in the evaluation of the structural
behavior of critical infrastructures under such particular
events. The activities presented in the current paper, part of
a wider research project—namely, the Tenza project—are
related to this topic.
The objective of the Tenza project is to study the effect of
high dynamic loads on a reinforced concrete (RC) arch
bridge that is part of the abandoned path of the Salerno-
Reggio Calabria highway. The bridge was built in the 1960s
and retrofitted in the 1990s. Four types of materials can be
identified in the Tenza Bridge: 1) the original concrete used
in the 1960s when the bridge was built—this accounts for
most of the concrete in the structure; 2) the concrete used to
strengthen the piers and arches; 3) the original lightly ribbed
steel used for the reinforcement of the original concrete; and
4) the new ribbed steel used as reinforcement of the more
recent RC portions.
In the first phase of the project, the structure was charac-
terized through static analysis under gravity and live loads
and a complete seismic assessment. The finite element
method (FEM) model used to perform these analyses was
validated by comparing the numerical vibration modes with
the results of a vibrodyne test. During such test, an evaluation of
the vibration modes was performed processing the acceleration
fields acquired using accelerometers distributed on the structure.
1
The objective of the second phase of the project was to
perform an assessment of the structure under severe dynamic
loads, such as impact or blast, through numerical analysis
and in-place tests. For this purpose, a dynamic characterization
of both concrete and steel of the Tenza Bridge, subjected to
severe dynamic load conditions, was performed; the results
of the activity conducted on concrete represents the specific
object of the current article.
In particular, high-strain-rate tensile failure tests were
conducted at the DynaMat Laboratory of the University of
Applied Sciences of Southern Switzerland, and stress-strain
relationships were then evaluated. The strain rate range of
interest for concrete was identified between 1 s
–1
and 50 s
–1
because these values are related to impact and blast load condi-
tions.
2
The obtained results, widely discussed in the following
paragraphs, are fundamental to define the influence of
dynamic loads on the constitutive behavior of materials aged
in a real structure and provide a reliable point of reference to
be used in structural analyses accounting for strain rate
effects. Indeed, knowledge of the dynamic behavior of both
structure and materials is essential to perform a complete
assessment of the bridge under impact or blast loads.
In particular, under such load conditions, two different
types of failure can be distinguished
3
: 1) local failure; and 2)
global failure.
The former can be due to an impact or an explosion occurring
close to structural elements; the characteristics of this failure
depend on the dynamic properties and ductility of the
element concerned and its constituent materials. By contrast,
global failure occurs after local failure and it is related to the
ability of the structure to withstand the loss of elements
without activating progressive collapse. It depends on global
ductility properties of the structure and on the quality and
frequency of connections between its elements. Obviously,
the more severe the local failure, the more likely global
failure is to occur.
Local failure can be distinguished into local failure of
materials and local failure of structural elements. The first
type of failure occurs when the explosion is so close to the
structure that the consequent shockwave in the air, impacting
on the surface of the element, causes a high field of compression
and propagates a tensile wave inside the material. Hence, these
stresses can cause the concrete to crack and, consequently,
a projection of debris. By contrast, the second type can occur
when the failure of one or more sections within the element
is activated.
4
Instead, global failure takes place after severe damage to
one or more structural elements, which can lead to progressive
Title no. 106-S12
Experimental Analysis on Tensile Dynamic Behavior
of Existing Concrete under High Strain Rates
by Domenico Asprone, Ezio Cadoni, and Andrea Prota