Journal of Modern Literature Vol. 44, No. 1 • Copyright © The Trustees of Indiana University • DOI 10.2979/jmodelite.44.1.09
Raymond Carver and the Modern Career
Imaginary
Jesse Zuba
Delaware State University
Almost without exception, critics endorse the idea that Raymond Carver’s Cathedral
marks a turn toward afrmation in the context of his career. Tat the stories
themselves strongly suggest otherwise shows the degree to which Carver studies
is enthralled by a redemptive career story propagated in part by Carver himself.
Tat narrative and its popularity derive from the poverty of the career imag-
inary, which favors a developmental logic unlikely to do justice to the complex
relations between texts. Reading Cathedral against the grain of the critical con-
sensus shows how Cathedral revisits the bleak perspective of his earlier work and
enables Carver to serve as an example of the need to enhance our understanding
of modern literary careers.
Keywords: Raymond Carver / modern career / Cathedral / surface reading /
development
“ I
t has been said, repeatedly,” writes Carol Sklenicka in Raymond Carver:
A Writer’s Life, “that the stories in Cathedral are fuller and more generous
than Carver’s previous work” (408). She adds a qualifcation: this “belief”
is founded on the diference between the “[Gordon] Lish-edited stories” in What
We Talk About When We Talk About Love and those in Cathedral, whereas “a truer
reckoning may be made” by comparing the earlier stories before they were cut by
Lish with the later ones (408). But even using the uncut stories for the comparison,
Sklenicka repeats yet again the claim that Cathedral is “fuller and more generous”
still and thus marks a critical juncture for Carver: it is a “book of richer perspective
Jesse Zuba (jzuba@desu.edu) is the author of Te First Book: Twentieth-Century Poetic
Careers in America (Princeton UP, 2016) and professor of English at Delaware State
University. His work has appeared in American Literature, Twentieth-Century Literature,
Te Wallace Stevens Journal, and elsewhere.