Towards consistent modes of e-health
implementation: structurational analysis of
a telecare programme’s limited success
Albert Boonstra & Marjolein van Offenbeek
University of Groningen, Faculty of Economics & Business, PO Box 800, 9700 AV
Groningen, The Netherlands, email: albert.boonstra@rug.nl; email:
m.a.g.van.offenbeek@rug.nl
Abstract. Telecare is the use of information and communication systems to
facilitate care delivery to individuals in their homes. Although the expectations of
telecare are high, its implementation has proved complex. This case study dem-
onstrates this complexity through a structurational analysis of a telecare imple-
mentation process. The paper shows how structuration concepts enable a
combined analysis of actors’ interactions with a technology and of the interaction
among these actors from different institutional contexts. In this example, frag-
mented multi-actor agency induced an inconsistent implementation mode, leading
to unsuccessful telecare appropriation. This paper concludes with a preliminary
proposal for more consistent telecare implementation modes. These modes may
better support the actors’ reflexive monitoring and dialogue and inform further
research.
Keywords: telecare, e-health, structurational model, stakeholders, institutional
context, implementation
INTRODUCTION
Most Western countries are facing a future with an aging population, and as a consequence,
rising health care costs (Poisal et al., 2007; OECD, 2009). A situation of increasing demands
for health care coupled with limited budgets encourages health care providers and insurers to
develop efficient ways to expand their current services. In achieving equal or even better
services at lower costs, information and communication technologies are portrayed as part of
the solution (Sauer & Willcocks, 2007). As a result, an e-health field has emerged that includes
health-related applications such as telemedicine, shared medical records, e-cure and domot-
ics. This paper offers a structurational analysis of the complexity inherent in implementing one
e-health application, telecare.
Telecare is the use of information and communication technology to facilitate health and
social care delivery to individuals in their homes (Barlow et al., 2006). The telecare technology
doi:10.1111/j.1365-2575.2010.00358.x
Info Systems J (2010) 20, 537–561 537
© 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd