IJESC, July 2020 26591 http:// ijesc.org/
ISSN 2321 3361 © 2020 IJESC
A Comparative Assessment on Production Cost and Output Yield of
Organic and Bt Cotton Farmers
Srushtideep Angidi
1
, Ajay Bogati
2
Banaras Hindu University, Uttar Pradesh, India
1
Lovely Professional University, Punjab, India
2
Abstract:
The recent years has seen a serious concern over the problem of environmental degradation and an urgent need for its
sustainability has been raised. To achieve a friendly and green environment, research discloses that organic farming can partly
offer a solution. The organic farming has its own benefits and hardship son farmer’s life. This paper therefore attempts to assess
the expenditure and margin incurred between organic cotton farmer and Bt cotton farmer. The study reveals that organic farmer
produced equivalent net income in some cases, even higher income compared to Bt farmers with much healthier biodiversity.
Keywords: Organic cotton, Bt cotton, Input cost and Economic output.
I. INTRODUCTION:
Current market trends reveal that organically produced
products are becoming widely accepted throughout the world.
As people around the globe are becoming aware of
introduction of a reckless chemical based agricultural policy
in the recent decades and their adverse impact on the health
and environment. Due to which they tend to approach towards
organic farming for healthier biodiversity. This increases the
demand of organic crop not only food and horticultural crops
but also various other cash crop and plantation crops. Of all
other cash crops, Cotton plays a dominant role in India’s
economy. Cotton and its value-added products are major
export earners for India’s national income. The Indian cotton
industry provides employment to more than 15 million people,
contributing 20% to the Gross National Product and 30% to
the total agricultural exports. (Subbiah and Jeyakumar, 2009).
Cotton is the only genetically engineered crop grown widely
in India, after being introduced during the last decade.
Genetically engineered cotton is also grown widely in China,
South Africa and the US. These genetically engineered cotton
varieties are known as ‘Bt cotton’. Bt cotton plants contain a
gene from the soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis, which
produces a toxin designed to kill a group of insect pests,
mostly larvae of moths, which are generally called ‘bollworm’
(Tirado,Reyes. 2010). The introduction of Bt cotton in 2002
pushed India to the rank of second-largest global producer of
cotton. Now in India almost 90% of the cotton cultivation area
is under Bt Cotton. The data, for the year 2010-11, shows that
out of total area of 111.42 lakh hectares under cotton
cultivation, 98.54 lakh hectares are under Bt Cotton. Since
most of the Bt cotton hybrids produce only the medium and
long staple lint, increase in area under Bt cotton has led to
decline in output of premium quality cotton. i.e. extra-long
staple cotton which fetches good price in the market. The only
safe conclusion from the studies carried out so far on Bt
cotton in India (and elsewhere) is that the performance and
impact of Bt technology are very variable and depend
critically upon a wide range of social, institutional, economic
and agronomic factors (Glover, 2009, Gruère et al., 2008,
Raney, 2006, Smalexet al., 2006). Research results about the
impacts of Bt cotton coming from econometric field based
studies in India draw a very polarised picture so far: one set of
studies claims to demonstrate its complete economical and
technical success and another set highlights the failures and
farmers’ hardships that have accompanied its introduction.
This has seriously distorted public debate and impeded the
development of sound, evidence-based policy” (Glover,
2009).
II. METHODOLOGY:
Data source
The study is absolutely based on primary data source, related
on various aspects of organic farming is collected from
farmers who were practicing the organic and Bt cotton
farming. Those details are used to calculate input and output
cost of production. The detailed information on quantities and
cost of different inputs used in production and labour used
was collected for this study.. For this study the survey was
conducted on farmers in the Jangaon district from Telangana.
The Jangaon district was purposively selected due to the fact
in the district efforts are being made by the CSA-Hyderabad
to help the farmers in adopting organic farming. The non-
adaptor of organic cotton farming where found to be Bt-
farmers. We compared the returns and input cost of Bt cotton
farmer and non Bt organic cotton farmers.
Sampling:
To make sure that all parameters for the survey was
invariable, apart genetically engineered seeds of Bt and the
chemicals used by conventional farmer all other agronomic
practices were kept as identical as possible between organic
farmer and Bt farmers.The problem with data collected from
farmer is that isn’t always analogous its rather contracting and
depends from farmer to farmer on their experience and the
knowledge they have acquired over years of farming.So we
tried to calculate an net average that would cost a single
farmer for one crop season based on the data collected from
the survey. In the survey, we collected data from total 12
farmer. Out of the 12 farmer,7 farmers were organic cotton
growers while the remaining 5 farmers were Bt cotton
growers. All Bt cotton farmers we encountered engage in
chemically intensive agriculture, with high use of pesticide
and chemical fertilisers while 5 out of 7 organic farmer were
certified producer and rest 2 farmer were in transition period.
Research Article Volume 10 Issue No.7