EPIDEMIOLOGY, PSYCHOLOGY AND PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
© 2004 The Medicine Publishing Company Ltd 11 PSYCHIATRY
The long and sometimes controversial history of the use of drugs
for the treatment of anxiety is at an interesting stage. As scientific
advances develop our understanding of human anxiety, public
interest in the field is growing and the range of therapeutic options
is increasing. Long-standing controversies such as the relative
merits of psychological therapies versus medication continue to
be debated, and the role of medication is still challenged from
some quarters (Nutt, 2003), but current practice guidelines draw
on a solid research base and substantial clinical experience. This
enables psychiatrists confidently to justify the treatment options
they offer to their patients. This contribution describes the place
of prescribing in the management of the anxious patient, outlines
the main classes of anxiolytic drugs and summarizes prescribing
guidance for the major anxiety disorders.
Clinical management of the anxious patient
Ideally, prescribing in anxiety occurs in the context of a careful
diagnostic assessment (Figure 1) (see also pages 16–21). Identifica-
tion of the correct diagnosis and the detection of any comorbidity,
such as depression and alcohol or substance misuse, will often
significantly modify treatment. The impact of the anxiety on
occupational, social or domestic functioning is assessed, and care
should be taken to highlight with the patient the key complaints
and the motivation for seeking treatment.
Once a diagnosis has been made, patients are offered an expla-
nation of the nature of their anxiety that is appropriate to their
level of understanding and ideally covers both the biological and
psychological dimensions. The use of educative literature may be
beneficial, and the recording and self-monitoring of symptoms
should be encouraged.
A treatment plan is devised by a process of negotiation. Either
biological or psychological treatments may be suitable, and a
Jon Nash is Lecturer in the Psychiatry of Old Age at the University of
Bristol, Bristol, UK. He trained in psychiatry in Manchester and Bristol,
and has worked at the Psychopharmacology Unit of the University of
Bristol since 1998. His research interests are the biology of anxiety
disorders and the effects of ageing on anxiety.
David J Nutt is Professor of Psychopharmacology at the University of
Bristol, Bristol, UK, and Honorary Consultant Psychiatrist, Avon and
Wiltshire Partnership Trust. His research interests include drugs used to
treat anxiety, depression and addiction, and the insights that the actions
of these give on the underlying brain pathologies.
Psychopharmacology
of anxiety
Jon Nash
David J Nutt
combination may be more effective than either alone. Patients
often have preconceptions about specific therapies, but an open
discussion of beneficial and adverse effects is likely to improve
compliance. Most anxiolytic medications are well tolerated, but
anxious patients are particularly sensitive to the experience of
side-effects. Progress is encouraged by regular review, particularly
in the early stages of treatment.
Anxiolytic drugs
The last 50 years have seen major developments in this field
(Figure 2). There is now a greater range of drugs available, and
the more modern medications are better tolerated – although not
necessarily more effective – than their predecessors. Increased
knowledge of the physiology of the brain has revealed that the
actions of current agents are moderated via a small number
of neurotransmitter systems only. The most important are the
monoamines and the amino acid neurotransmitters (chiefly
γ-aminobutyric acid, GABA).
1
Assessment and management of a patient with anxiety
disorder
Diagnostic assessment
Presenting problem Mental state examination
Psychiatric/medical history Physical examination
Family/personal history Investigations
Drug and alcohol history Rating scales
History from informant
Management
Psychoeducation + use of literature
Self-monitoring of symptoms
Negotiation of treatment plan
Medication
Psychological therapy
Regular review
Primary diagnosis of anxiety disorder
(GAD, OCD, panic disorder, PTSD, social anxiety disorder)
+ Comorbidity + Functional impairment
Second anxiety disorder Domestic
Depression Occupational
Drug/alcohol problem Social