Impact of Mg Doping on Performances of CuGaO
2
Based p‑Type
Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells
Ade ̀ le Renaud,
†
Laurent Cario,*
,†
Philippe Deniard,
†
Eric Gautron,
†
Xavier Rocquefelte,
†
Yann Pellegrin,
‡
Errol Blart,
‡
Fabrice Odobel,
‡
and Ste ́ phane Jobic*
,†
†
Institut des Mate ́ riaux Jean Rouxel, Universite ́ de Nantes, CNRS, 2 rue de la Houssinie ̀ re, BP 32229, 44322 Nantes, Cedex 03,
France
‡
Universite ́ LUNAM, Universite ́ de Nantes, CNRS, Chimie et Interdisciplinarite ́ : Synthè se, Analyse, Mode ́ lisation (CEISAM), UMR
6230, 2 rue de la Houssinie ̀ re, 44322 Nantes, Cedex 03, France
ABSTRACT: p-Type dye solar cells (p-DSSCs) have been
receiving much attention due to their potential role in the
elaboration of future tandem dye solar cells with a photoanode
and a photocathode built upon n-type and a p-type
semiconductors, respectively. So far, NiO appears as the
most widely used semiconductor in p-DSSCs. Yet this material
suffers from several drawbacks, e.g., a low electrical
conductivity and a low redox potential that limit the
photovoltaic performances. In that framework, delafossite
compounds may be regarded as appropriate substitutes of
nickel oxide in relation to their intrinsic optoelectronic
properties. Here we report on the nanostructuration of
CuGaO
2
and its Mg doped derivatives via hydrothermal conditions with Pluronic P123 as surfactant. It appears that a low
amount of magnesium helps in preparing samples with higher specific surface areas and stimulates enhanced conversion
efficiencies. Beyond a given Ga/Mg substitution rate, a new Cu
1‑x
(Ga,Mg)O
2
phase is formed that contains a large amount of Cu
vacancies and of structural defects. This new phase shows lower photovoltaic performances compared to those for slightly doped
derivatives which suggests that Cu vacancies and/or structural defects limit the mean free path of holes within the photocathode.
■
INTRODUCTION
Solar cells based on the sensitization of a p-type semiconductor
are of growing interest to researchers.
1-7
The development of
such devices appears as the mandatory step to achieve tandem
dye-sensitized solar cells (t-DSSCs) with a photoanode built
upon a conventional n-type semiconductor (n-SC, e.g., TiO
2
and ZnO)
8,9
and a photocathode built upon a p-type
semiconductor (p-SC, e.g., NiO and CuO),
1,2,10
both electro-
des being sensitized by two distinct dyes. The fabrication of
such devices would open up the door to higher efficiencies in
the conversion of sunlight into electrical power compared to n-
DSSCs alone as demonstrated by He et al.,
11
Odobel et al.,
12
and Nattestad et al.
13
Unfortunately, p-DSSCs performances
are currently very low compared with those of n-DSSCs, and
intensive work has to be dedicated to the quest to find new
nanostructurated p-SCs to favor higher open-circuit voltage
(V
OC
), short-circuit current (J
SC
), and fill factor (ff).
14
To date,
the most frequently used p-SC in p-DSSCs remains by far NiO
with a common conversion efficiency (η) of a few tens of a
percent. Nevertheless, it is worth noticing that a real
breakthrough was recently discovered by Powar et al.
15
where
NiO is coupled with the outstanding PMI-6T-TPA dye as a
sensitizer and tris(1,2-diaminoethane)cobalt(II/III) complexes
as a redox mediator to reach a η value of 1.3%. Moreower, new
p-SCs were recently explored to replace NiO and significant
success were achieved with delafossites.
3-6,16,17
The limited
performances of NiO-based solar cells were so far in part
attributed to a too high energy position of the top of its valence
band. In that framework, we have embarked recently on the
synthesis of p-type CuGaO
2
-delafossite nanoparticles in
ethylene glycol (EG) mediated hydrothermal conditions.
18
Namely electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) meas-
urements on NiO and CuGaO
2
samples evidenced an increase
of the flat band potentials (FBP) by almost 200 mV shifting
from the binary to the ternary compounds. Unfortunately, this
significant enhancement of the FBP does not go along with an
increase of the p-DSSCs performances, owing to a still low
short circuit photocurrent (Jsc) likely due to unoptimized p-
SC/dye and dye/mediator interfaces favoring counter-produc-
tive reactions. This may also be associated with a relatively low
absorbance of the photocathode suggesting that the size of
prepared CuGaO
2
particles is still too large leading to low
specific surface area and finally a low amount of adsorbed dyes
on its surface. An increase of J
SC
in CuGaO
2
based DSSCs
appears therefore as the key point to outperform NiO based
cells. For that purpose, it is crucial to obtain smaller
Received: July 22, 2013
Revised: December 10, 2013
Published: December 11, 2013
Article
pubs.acs.org/JPCC
© 2013 American Chemical Society 54 dx.doi.org/10.1021/jp407233k | J. Phys. Chem. C 2014, 118, 54-59