978-1-4673-8292-2/16/$31.00 ©2016 IEEE
Laboratory tests
of a high-precision laser interferometry readout
for the GG experiment in space
Marco Pisani and Massimo Zucco
INRIM-Istituto Nazionale di Ricerca Metrologica
Via delle Cacce 91, Torino, Italy
Email: marco.pisani@inrim.it
massimo.zucco@inrim.it
Anna M. Nobili
Department of Physics “E. Fermi”
University of Pisa
and INFN-Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
Largo B. Pontecorvo 3, 56127 Pisa, Italy
Email: anna.nobili@unipi.it
Abstract—On 25 April the Microscope satellite was successfully
launched to test the weak equivalence principle, which is the
founding pillar of General Relativity, to to 1 part in 10
15
(100-
fold improvement). A possible violation will potentially be a
major discovery and call for urgent checking. The GG (“Galileo
Galilei”) satellite experiment can do that with one hundred times
better precision, to 10
-17
. To do that GG is required to measure
the relative displacements of two concentric test cylinders with a
precision of about half a picometer at the frequency of 1 Hz.A
laser interferometry gauge has been designed for this purpose
and is under development at INRIM with a required noise
level of
1 pm
√
Hz
at 1 Hz. We report recent experimental results
which demonstrate that the requirement can be met with a free
running laser (no frequency lock needed) and consequent reduced
complexity.
I. I NTRODUCTION
In a gravitational field all bodies fall with the same ac-
celeration regardless of their mass and composition. This is
the Universality of Free Fall-UFF (also known as the Weak
Equivalence Principle-WEP). As stated by Einstein in his 1916
paper “The foundation of the general theory of relativity”[1],
this ‘fact of nature’ is at the foundation of the General theory
of Relativity (GR) and must therefore be firmly supported
by experiments. In 1916 Einstein brought as experimental
evidence the best tests of his time carried out in Budapest
by Lor` and von E¨ otv¨ os and his group, referring to the great
accuracy of these tests in a specific footnote of his paper.
The results of E¨ otv¨ os were indeed astonishing. While all his
predecessors since Galileo had suspended different test masses
from pendulums, E¨ otv¨ os had the great intuition of coupling
them by suspension on a single torsion balance, and in so
doing improved the precision of the test by three orders of
magnitude.
One century later the best controlled laboratory tests of
UFF-WEP are still provided by torsion balances, now rotating
in order to modulate the signal and up-covert its frequency to
higher values (the higher the better) where thermal noise, elec-
tronics noise and other noise sources are known to be smaller.
In a remarkable series of experiments with slowly rotating
torsion balances the E¨ ot-Wash group of Eric Adelberger at
the University of Washington has confirmed UFF-WEP to 1
part in 10
13
in the gravitational field of the Earth [2], [3]. A
similar result has been obtained for the Moon and the Earth
falling in the gravitational field of the Sun by laser ranging to
the retroreflectors left by the astronauts on the surface of the
Moon ([4], [5]).
Gravity is the only fundamental force of nature to obey the
equivalence principle. The equivalence principle is therefore
at the crossroad between General Relativity and the Standard
Model of particle physics, and for this reason a huge amount
of theoretical work has been carried out in trying to establish
at which level a breakdown –if any– should occur. Till now
these efforts have failed to provide us with a firm target. Thus,
similarly to Einstein and E¨ otv¨ os one hundred years ago, we
consider the best tests available and how they can be further
improved,
A violation of UFF-WEP would signal that either GR needs
fixing, or a new force of nature has been found. Either way it
would be a scientific revolution. This is why experimentalists
have tried to test it with better and better precision whenever
the possibility for an improvement has arisen.
Tests of the Universality of Free Fall are quantified by the
fractional differential acceleration
η =
Δa
a
(1)
between two test masses of different composition as they fall
in the gravitational field of a source body with the average
acceleration a (the “driving signal”). The physical observable
quantity is the differential acceleration Δa of the falling
masses relative to each other, pointing to the center of mass
of the source body (e.g. the Earth). For UFF-WEP to hold it
must be η =0; the lower the value of η, the more sensitive is
the test.
For the same experimental sensitivity to Δa, the higher the
driving acceleration a (at the denominator of (1)), the more
sensitive is the test. If the test masses are suspended inside a
satellite orbiting the Earth at low altitude rather than being on
a torsion balance on the ground, the gain due to the driving
260