FRED CAHIR, RANI KERIN AND KYLIE RIPPON
The Aboriginal Adjustment Movement in Colonial
Victoria
Whilst much has been written about Aboriginal religious syncretism in Australia, par-
ticularly about what has become known as the “ Adjustment Movement” that occurred
in Arnhem Land in the 1950s (see McIntosh 2004), there were several remarkable
examples of spiritual adjustment by Aboriginal people a century earlier on the Victo-
rian goldfields that hitherto have not been explored by historians. Building on
Magowan’ s (2003) discussion of the connection between Christianity and the ancestral
law of Aboriginal culture in northern Australia, this article will examine how Christian
influences in colonial Victoria competed with, and conversely moulded, southern Kulin
ancestral understanding. Several Kulin ceremonies — including the Myndee ceremony
and the “Veinie Sacred Sunday Dance”— will be examined. These ceremonies were
described by colonial officials (Joseph Panton, a Gold Commissioner, and William
Thomas, the Aboriginal Guardian of Aborigines in Victoria) in the midst of a second
wave of invasion and rupture for Victorian Aboriginal people — the first being the
sheep herders in the 1830s, and the second being the gold rush which commenced in
1851. Serving as exemplars of what might be called the Victorian Aboriginal Adjust-
ment Movement, these ceremonies demonstrate the extent to which Aboriginal people
on the goldfields of Victoria engaged in a culturally congruent mode of Christianity.
In 1981 anthropologist and historian Diane Barwick proffered a blistering
analysis of her fellow academics’ approach to Aboriginal Christianity:
Academics are rarely scornful about indigenous religious beliefs. These are exotic,
ethnic and acceptable. Christian beliefs are not accorded equivalent respect as cul-
tural markers. The acceptance of Christian religion by Aboriginal communities is
either ignored or lamented by anthropologists and historians. No other aspect of
Aboriginal life has been so deliberately unexamined.
1
Fred Cahir is an Associate Professor, Faculty of Education and Arts, Federation University
Australia, PO Box 663, Ballarat, 3353, VIC, Australia.
Kylie Rippon is a HDR candidate in the Faculty of Education and Arts, Federation University
Australia, PO Box 663, Ballarat, 3353, VIC, Australia.
Dr Rani Kerin is an academic in the Faculty of Education and Arts, Federation University Australia,
PO Box 663, Ballarat, 3353, VIC, Australia.
1. It should be noted that Barwick did acknowledge the general deleterious impact of missionar-
ies on Australian Indigenous people, as part of the invasion and colonisation process.
D. Barwick, “Writing Aboriginal History: Comments on a Book and its Reviewers, ” Canberra
Anthropology 4 (1981): 74–86.
1
© 2019 Religious History Association
Journal of Religious History
Vol. ••, No. ••, 2019
doi: 10.1111/1467-9809.12630