International
Journal of Social
Economics
24,1/2/3
128
Fishery management,
environmental protection and
trade liberalization
H.F. Campbell
University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
A. McIlgorm
Australian Maritime College, Australia, and
B.M. Tsamenyi
University of Wollongong, Wollongong, Australia
1 Introduction
This paper is concerned with the management of the marine environment. The
marine environment generates a flow of goods and services and the objective of
management is assumed to be to maximize the sustainable value of that flow.
T he values generated by the marine environment can be classified as either use
or non-use values: examples of use values are direct uses such as commercial
fishing or recreation in the form of fishing and diving, and indirect uses such as
viewing film of marine life; examples of non-use values include existence,
bequest and option values (see Adamowicz et al., 1991).
Recent developments in the theory and practice of fishery management
(DPIE, 1989) have resulted in increases in the use value of many commercial
fisheries. Examples are New Zealand’s commercial fisheries which are
regulated by individual transferable quotas (ITQs) (see Clark et al., 1988), and
the British Columbia halibut fishery which is regulated by individual vessel
quotas (see Casey et al., 1995). These gains have been achieved by creating
property rights to exploit and benefit from the fishery: this is a direct response
to the view that the absence of individual property rights to fish stocks leads to
over-fishing in a market economy.
While property rights to the use values of marine environments can be
established and, in many cases, enforced at reasonable cost, this is usually not
an option in the case of non-use values. Non-use values are pure public goods: if
provided to one person they are provided to all, and one person’s consumption
of a public good does not reduce the amount of the good available to others. It
has long been recognized that a fundamental role of government is the
provision of public goods such as law and order and defence. If the appropriate
levels of non-use values are to be generated by marine environments it will be as
a result of government regulation such as, for example, the setting and
enforcing of environmental standards necessary to support viable populations
(see T isdell and Hohl, 1993).
International Journal of Social
Economics, Vol. 24 No. 1/2/3, 1997,
pp. 128-138. © MCB University
Press, 0306-8293