Proceedings of the 8
th
International Conference on
Sustainable Development in the Minerals Industry
www.camdemia.ca/publications, press@camdemia.ca
Editors: Z.X. Li, Z. Agioutantis and D.H. Zou
ISBN: 978-0-9948791-3-4
SDIMI 2017: 68-71
* Corresponding Author: K. Koitsiwe, kegomoditswek@yahoo.com, phone: +81 80-6292-3841
Copyright © 2017 Canamaple Academia Services, http://press.camdemia.ca DOI: 10.15273/gree.2017.02.013
68
The Impact of Structure Change on Copper Prices
Kegomoditswe Koitsiwe
1*
and Tsuyoshi Adachi
2
1
Graduate School of Engineering and Resource Science, Akita University, Japan
2
Graduate School of International Resource Science, Akita University, Japan
Abstract: This paper characterizes quarterly LME copper price fundamentals from 1995 to 2011 by analyzing the
transformation of the market mechanism based on structural change perspective. Using chow test for structural change based
on the least square multiple regression, we divide the price fluctuation into: Stable price period (1995Q3-1999Q2), Low
stable price period (1999Q3 – 2003Q3) and Price fluctuation period (2003Q4 – 2011Q2). The results show the existence of
structural breaks disproves the investigation of the full sample period as a whole. In different structural breakpoints the main
drivers of copper prices changes and their impact are significantly different. Moreover, the paper examines the role of
speculation in copper price fluctuations.
Keywords: copper price fundamentals, speculation, structural breaks
1. Introduction
The rise in commodities price volatility and financial and
economic crisis have led to questions over the organisation
of futures and physical commodities markets. Spikes in
commodity prices and volatility have coincided with a surge
in financial speculators in the commodity markets inspiring
a polarised and hotly debate among academics and
practitioners about the role of investors in the development
of physical markets. In his seminal work Kaldor (1939)
focused primarily on whether speculative activity in the
futures markets reduces the variance of commodity spot
prices. Yet, part of the literature finds that the introduction
of futures contracts destabilizes the spot market. IMF (2006)
studied commodities boom and its causes concluding that
there is little support for the hypothesis that speculative
activity affects either price levels over the long run or price
swings in the short-run. The impact of speculative activity
on commodity prices remains a highly contentious topic.
Other market analysts take the view that the supply and
demand for physical commodities remain the major
determinants of market trends (Krugman 2008). It is the aim
of this study to contribute to the literature by examining the
drivers of copper price changes from a structural change
perspective. In this context we are attempting to answer to:
What are the main drivers leading to copper price
fluctuations? Are these factors having the same effect in
different periods or not? It is meaningful to understand
drivers of copper prices and thereby, their fluctuations
because it will help developing countries depending on
copper export to anticipate market situation and avoid bad
economic development challenges that can result from price
fluctuations. Moreover, this can ensure sustainable mineral
supply.
2. Investment in Commodity Markets
Investing in commodities is subject to greater scrutiny due
to the implication that demand and supply patterns in these
markets may have on the economy at large. Financial crisis
has seen an increase in the weight of investors shifting from
purely financial asset classes to instruments with an
underlying commodity or close proxy. This is because
commodities do not easily go out of market therefore can be
used as an inflation hedge. Investing directly in
commodities is however, very costly due to the
unpredictable factors that can change their price patterns
and cash needed to cover daily margin calls for marked-to
market futures positions. The investment strategies in
commodities are manifold.
Investors can buy and sell commodity futures and
traded options on exchanges, such as London Metal
Exchange (LME) or the New York Commodity Exchange
(COMEX). Deals can be directly conducted over-the-
counter (OTC). They can buy commodity-based Exchange
Traded Funds or buy and take physical possession of
commodity stocks. Investors use the markets to hedge their
business from the various risks linked to commodities.
Another trading objective is generated from the need for
liquidity or funding relief (Aramendía and Lannoo 2012).
Spotting a divergence between futures and spot prices at
maturity is an example of arbitrage. If the future price at
maturity is lower than the spot price, the commodity firm
will exploit this situation by buying the futures rather than
the spot. The important aspect of this transaction is that is a
risk-free operation. Informed trading, also known as
speculation is a form of trading based on investments in
private information, which the trader exploits to generate
profits.