Demography, Vol. 27, No.1, February 1990
Pregnancy Wantedness and the Early Initiation of
Prenatal Care
Theodore J. Joyce
Department of Health Care Administration,
Baruch College, City University of New York,
and National Bureau of Economic Research, 269
Mercer Street, New York, New York 10003
Michael Grossman
Graduate Center, City University of New York,
and National Bureau of Economic Research, 269
Mercer Street, New York, New York 10003
The study examines the impact of the wantedness of a pregnancy on the demand for
early prenatal care. Using a cohort of pregnant women in New YorkCity, we estimate
a prenatal care demand function in which we control for the probability of giving
birth, given a woman is pregnant. We interpret this control as a measure of wantedness,
The results indicate that if the black and Hispanic women who aborted had instead
given birth, they would have delayed the initiation of prenatal care, on average, more
than three-quarters of a month longer than the mean number of months of delay that
were actually observed for the women who gave birth. Byallowing women to terminate
an unwanted pregnancy, induced abortion increases the average use of prenatal care
among black and Hispanic women relative to what would have been observed if the
women who aborted had instead given birth.
Two recent and comprehensive reports on infant health in the United States both
recommended that efforts be directed at reducing the number of unintended or unwanted
pregnancies (Institute of Medicine 1985; U. S. Dept. of Health and Human Services 1986).
The recommendation was based on the proposed link between pregnancy planning, improved
prenatal behavior, and favorable birth outcomes. Specifically, women who choose to become
pregnant are apt to be better prepared emotionally and financially for the demands of
pregnancy and childbearing. Thus they may be more likely to avoid smoking, to seek out
prenatal care earlier, and in general to have a more heightened concern for the impact of
their behavior on the health of the fetus than are women whose pregnancies are unwanted
or unintended.
As plausible as the recommendation appears, the evidence supporting it is scarce, A
number of ecological analyses have documented a relationship between the use of family
planning clinics and lower rates of neonatal mortality (Grossman & Jacobowitz 1981; Joyce
1987a). The availability and use of abortion services have also been associated with im-
provements in area-wide birth outcomes (Corman & Grossman 1985; Joyce 1987b). These
authors argue that the use of contraception and abortion should be inversely related to the
incidence of unwanted pregnancies and births and positively related to the increased use of
prenatal care and other healthy behaviors,
At the individual level, there is some evidence that women who describe their births
as wanted begin prenatal care earlier and smoke less during pregnancy (Marsiglio & Mott
1988; Weller, Eberstein, & Bailey 1987), The methodological problems of using self-as-
Copyright © 1990 Population Association of America
Downloaded from http://read.dukeupress.edu/demography/article-pdf/27/1/1/904368/1joyce.pdf by guest on 20 December 2021