Soil Science Society of America Journal
Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 81:392–403
doi:10.2136/sssaj2016.07.0221
Received 18 July 2016.
Accepted 12 Jan. 2017.
*Corresponding author (lars.munkholm@agro.au.dk).
© Soil Science Society of America, 5585 Guilford Rd., Madison WI 53711 USA. All Rights reserved.
Eleven Years’ Effect of Conservation Practices for
Temperate Sandy Loams: II. Soil Pore Characteristics
Soil & Water Management & Conservation
Conservation agriculture (CA) is regarded by many as a sustainable inten-
sifcation strategy. Minimal soil disturbance in combination with residue
retention are important CA components. This study examined the long-term
effects of crop rotation, residue retention, and tillage on soil pore character-
istics of two Danish sandy loams. Rotation R2 is a rotation of winter crops
(mainly cereals) with residues retained, rotation R3 a mix of winter and
spring crops (mainly cereals) with residues removed, and rotation R4 the
same mix of winter and spring crops, but with residues retained. Each rota-
tion included the tillage treatments: moldboard plowing to 20-cm depth
(MP), harrowing to 8- to 10-cm depth (H) and direct drilling (D). Soil cores
were taken from the topsoil (4–8, 12–16, 18–27 cm) in mid-autumn 2013 and
early spring 2014. Water retention, air permeability, and gas diffusivity was
determined for the frst two depths (100-cm
3
cores), and air permeability
for the 18- to 27-cm depth (250-cm
3
cores). Moldboard plowing resulted in
the best soil quality at two upper depths with higher total porosity, air-flled
porosity, air permeability, and gas diffusivity compared with reduced tillage.
For instance, the volume of pores > 30 µm was more than 0.03 m
3
m
-3
larger
for MP than for D in spring 2014 at the 4- to 8-cm depth. At the 18- to 27-cm
depth, direct drilling resulted in a better air permeability and pore continuity
index (e.g., air permeability of 18.2 and 11.2 mm
2
for D and MP, respective-
ly at −10 kPa for the Foulum location). Residue retention, especially when
combined with direct drilling, increased total porosity, air-flled porosity, air
permeability, and gas diffusivity and decreased blocked air porosities. Our
results suggest residue management can be used to alleviate the negative
effects of reduced tillage on soil structural quality.
Abbreviations: CA, conservation agriculture; D, direct drilling; H, harrowing to an 8- to
10-cm depth; MP, moldboard plowing to a 20-cm depth; PO, pore organization.
S
ustainability of agricultural practices is of growing concern because of in-
creased food, feed and fuel demand, and the impact on the environment
and climate change and its consequences (European Commission, 2015;
FAO, 2017). Proper soil management is a prerequisite for sustainable agriculture
and therefore there is strong focus on soil management strategies to mitigate soil
degradation and improve soil quality (Lal, 2015). Conservation agriculture has
been suggested as a means to improve the delivery of ecosystem services from
agricultural systems (Palm et al., 2014). Minimal soil disturbance, crop rotation,
and residue retention are regarded as the key components of CA (Torres et al.,
2001; Verhulst et al., 2010; Wall, 2007). According to the EU Thematic Strategy
(http://ec.europa.eu/environment/soil/three_en.htm), one of the specific soil
functions for food production is: “the pathway through which water and nutri-
ents move to roots, whether from soil reserves or from external inputs” (Powlson
et al., 2011). The key structural part of soil that fulfills this specific function is
the soil pore network.
Lotfollah Abdollahi
Department of Agroecology
Aarhus University
Research Centre Foulum
P.O. Box 50
DK-8830 Tjele
Denmark
Faculty of Agriculture
Payame Noor University (PNU)
P.O. Box 19395-3697
Tehran, Iran
Lars Juhl Munkholm*
Department of Agroecology
Aarhus University
Research Centre Foulum
P.O. Box 50
DK-8830 Tjele
Denmark
Core Ideas
• Long-term effects of tillage, rotation,
and residue management studied.
• Residue retention increased porosity,
air permeability, and gas diffusivity.
• Residue retention alleviated negative
effects of reduced tillage on soil pores.
• Moldboard plowing caused best
topsoil (0-20 cm depth) quality.
• Direct drilling resulted in highest air
permeability at the 18- to 27-cm depth.
Published April 20, 2017