Int. J. Project Organisation and Management, Vol. 7, No. 2, 2015 151
Copyright © 2015 Inderscience Enterprises Ltd.
A performance evaluation framework of construction
projects: insights from literature
Christopher Ngacho* and Debadyuti Das
Faculty of Management Studies,
University of Delhi,
Delhi – 110 007, India
Email: cngacho@yahoo.com
Email: ddas@fms.edu
*Corresponding author
Abstract: The present work attempts to develop a theoretical framework of the
performance evaluation of construction projects based on six key performance
indicators (KPIs) namely time, cost, quality, safety, minimum site disputes and
environmental impact. These KPIs were identified through literature review
and discussions with project management professionals. For evaluating the
performance on the above KPIs, several characteristic features pertaining to the
project, project environment and the stakeholders associated with the project
have been identified through an extensive literature review. These
characteristic features, termed as critical success factors (CSFs), have been
suitably classified under six broad heads based on their commonalities and
unique features. The six CSFs are named as project-related, client-related,
consultant-related, contractor-related, supply chain-related and external
environment-related factors. We have demonstrated the relationship between
CSFs and overall project performance with the help of a conceptual diagram.
The diagram reveals how the factors influence the performance of a
construction project and also how the factors themselves are related to each
other. In addition, it also shows how the overall performance leads to
community satisfaction. This has been discussed through a set of nine
propositions. We have concluded by highlighting the contributions of the paper
to the existing body of project management literature.
Keywords: construction project; project performance; key performance
indicators; KPIs; critical success factors; CSFs; propositions.
Reference to this paper should be made as follows: Ngacho, C. and Das, D.
(2015) ‘A performance evaluation framework of construction projects: insights
from literature’, Int. J. Project Organisation and Management, Vol. 7, No. 2,
pp.151–173.
Biographical notes: Christopher Ngacho is a doctoral research scholar in the
Faculty of Management Studies, University of Delhi, Delhi. He is doing his
doctoral research on developing a performance evaluation framework of
construction projects based on constituency development fund (CDF)
construction projects in Kenya. He obtained his MBA from the University of
Nairobi. His research interests include project management, application of
operations research techniques in management and contemporary issues in
operations management.
Debadyuti Das is an Associate Professor in the Faculty of Management
Studies, University of Delhi, Delhi. His current research interests include
reverse supply chain management, sustainable supply chain management,