VOL. 4, NO. 5, JULY 2009 ISSN 1819-6608
ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences
© 2006-2009 Asian Research Publishing Network (ARPN). All rights reserved.
www.arpnjournals.com
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATIONS IN A CIRCULAR TUBE
TO ENHANCE TURBULENT HEAT TRANSFER
USING MESH INSERTS
Naga Sarada S., Kalyani K. Radha and A. V. S. Raju
Department of Mechanical Engineering, JNTUH College of Engineering, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, India
E-Mail: kalyaniradha@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
The present work shows the results obtained from experimental investigations of the augmentation of turbulent
flow heat transfer in a horizontal tube by means of mesh inserts with air as the working fluid. Sixteen types of mesh inserts
with screen diameters of 22mm, 18mm, 14mm and 10mm for varying distance between the screens of 50mm, 100mm,
150mm and 200mm in the porosity range of 99.73 to 99.98 are considered for experimentation. The Reynolds number is
varied from 7000 to 14000. Correlations for Nusselt number and friction factor are developed for the mesh inserts from the
obtained results. It is observed that the enhancement of heat transfer by using mesh inserts when compared to plain tube at
the same mass flow rate is more by a factor of 2 times where as the pressure drop is only about a factor of 1.45 times.
Keywords: tube, heat transfer, mesh, turbulent flow, pressure drop, augmentation.
INTRODUCTION
In the recent years, considerable emphasis has
been placed on the development of various augmented
heat transfer surfaces and devices. This can be seen from
the exponential increase in world technical literature
published in heat transfer augmentation devices, growing
patents and hundreds of manufacturers offering products
ranging from enhanced tubes to entire thermal systems
incorporating enhancement technology. Energy and
materials saving considerations, space considerations as
well as economic incentives have led to the increased
efforts aimed at producing more efficient heat exchanger
equipment through the augmentation of heat transfer.
Among many techniques investigated for augmentation of
heat transfer rates inside circular tubes, a wide range of
inserts have been utilized, particularly when turbulent flow
is considered. The inserts studied included twisted tape
inserts, coil wire inserts, brush inserts, mesh inserts, strip
inserts etc. The utilization of porous inserts has proved to
be very promising in heat transfer augmentation. One of
the important porous media characteristics is represented
by an extensive contact surface between solid and fluid
surfaces. The extensive contact surface enhances the
internal heat exchange between the phases and
consequently results in an increased thermal diffusivity.
Different types of porous materials are extensively studied
in forced convection heat transfer due to the wide range of
potential engineering applications such as electronic
cooling, drying processes, solid matrix heat exchangers,
heat pipe, enhanced recovery of petroleum reservoirs etc.
however the experimental work carried out in this area is
limited.
Experimental studies conducted for heat transfer
and pressure drop of laminar flow in horizontal tubes
with/without longitudinal inserts (Shou-Shing Hsieh et al.,
2003). They reported that enhancement of heat transfer as
compared to a conventional bare tube at the same
Reynolds number to be a factor of 16 at Re <= 4000, while
a friction factor rise of only 4.5. Hsieh and Kuo (Shou-
Shing Hsieh et al., 2003) conducted experimental
investigations for the augmentation of tube side heat
transfer in a cross flow heat exchanger for turbulent flow
of air by means of strip type inserts. They found that
longitudinal strip inserts perform better than crossed strip
(CS) and regularly interrupted strip (RIS) inserts for high
Reynolds number (Shou-Shing Hsieh et al., 2003). Hsieh
and Wu (Shou-Shing Hsieh et al., 2000) conducted
experimental studies on heat transfer and flow
characteristics for turbulent flow of air in a horizontal
circular tube with strip type inserts (longitudinal and
Crossed Strip inserts). They reported that friction factor
rise due to inclusion of inserts was typically between 1.1
and 1.5 from low Re (=6500) to high Re (=19500) with
respect to bare tube. The experimental investigations of
Hsieh and Liu (Shou-Shing Hsieh et al., 1996) report that
Nusselt numbers were between four and two times the
bare values at low Re and high Re respectively. Bogdan
I.Pavel (Bogdan I. Pavel et al., 2004) experimentally
investigated the effect of metallic porous inserts in a pipe
subjected to constant and uniform heat flux at a Reynolds
number range of 1000-4500. The maximum increase in the
length-averaged Nu number of about 5.2 times in
comparison with the clear flow case and a highest pressure
drop of 64.8Pa were reported with a porous medium fully
filling the pipe.
Angirasa (Devarakonda Angirasa, 2001)
performed experiments that proved augmentation of heat
transfer by using metallic fibrous materials with two
different porosities namely 97% and 93%. The
experiments were carried out for different Reynolds
numbers (17,000-29,000) and power inputs (3.7 and 9.2
W). The improvement in the average Nusselt number was
about 3-6 times in comparison with the case when no
porous material was used. Fu (Fu.H.L et al., 2001)
experimentally demonstrated that a channel filled with
high conductivity porous material subjected to oscillating
53