Impact of Dissolved Oxygen and Anoxic Decay on the Longterm
OModeling of Simultaneous Nitrification and Denitrification
(SNdN) in a Pilot Scale MBR
M.Sarioglu
1*
, G.nsel
2
, N.Artan
2
, D.Orhon
3
1
MWH UK Ltd. Dubai, P.O.Box 3020, United Arab Emirates
2
Istanbul Technical University, Environmental Engineering Department, Maslak, 34469,
Istanbul, Turkey
3
Turkish Academy of Sciences, Piyade sokak No.27, 06550, Çankaya, Ankara, Turkey
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. Email: murat.sarioglu@uk.mwhglobal.com
ABSTRACT
This study is mainly focused on evaluating the impact of dissolved oxygen and anoxic decay
on simultaneous nitrification and denitrification (SNdN) in a pilot scale membrane bioreactor
(MBR). Nitrate utilization rates for anoxic and MBR tanks were calculated from a previously
calibrated model to quantify the effect of each tank on the total nitrogen removal capability of
the system. The total average nitrate utilization rate (NUR
t
) in the membrane tank was 2.3
mg/L-h (4.6 gN/kgVSS-d) throughout the study where 65% of this was associated with the
anoxic decay process having the major contribution to SNdN. The denitrification potential
(N
DP
) of the MBR tank corresponded to 75% of the total N
DP
of the system at an average DO
level of 1 mg/L and decreased with increasing DO. The comparative steady state modeling
revealed that MBR systems have the potential to provide 60% more total nitrogen removal
efficiency at a DO level of 2 mg/L when compared to conventional systems with the same
operating parameters. It was found that in a MBR system the existence of the anoxic tank is
questionable at low DO concentrations because of the low levels of nitrate being recirculated
back to the this tank due to the high N
DP
in the membrane tank.
KEYWORDS: membrane bioreactor, simultaneous nitrification/denitrification,
denitrification potential, nitrate utilization rate, denitrification potential, diffusion limitation
INTRODUCTION
Nitrogen removal requires the inclusion of an unaerated volume fraction into the activated
sludge process to sustain anoxic conditions that will favor the uptake of nitrate as the final
electron acceptor during the growth of heterotrophic microorganisms. This is done either
before the aeration tank which is called pre-denitrification or after which is defined as the
post denitrification scheme. Pre-denitrification is mostly favored as it takes advantage of the
available carbon in the raw or settled sewage for the conventional activated sludge systems
(CASS). Membrane bioreactor (MBR) systems have the same type of process scheme for
nitrogen removal however it differs with its ability to sustain higher biomass concentrations
as the solids-liquid separation is independent from the biomass settling properties. The
complete biomass retention enables the system to be operated at higher sludge ages and thus
resulting in lower excess sludge production with respect to CASS (Günder, 2001).
The conceptual basis of nitrogen removal has been fully investigated and understood for
conventional activated sludge systems in previous researches (Ekama et al.,1983, Avcıolu et
al., 1998; Sözen et al., 2002; Artan et al., 2006). However studies on the nitrogen removal
performance of MBR systems did not cover the fundamental aspects of process kinetics and
modeling especially taking into account the higher biomass concentrations sustained in the
WEFTEC 2009
Copyright ©2009 Water Environment Federation. All Rights Reserved.
2711