3491
Journal of Critical Reviews
ISSN- 2394-5125 Vol 7, Issue 17, 2020
Review Article
CRITICAL DISCOURSE ANALYSIS OF PRESIDENT TRUMP’S SPEECHES ABOUT IMMIGRANTS
SIROUS ABEDINI
Ph.D. in Linguistics, Gelisim University, Istanbul, Turkey
Received: 10 Aug 2019 Revised and Accepted: 26 Oct 2019
ABSTRACT
Racism is defined (Van Dijk, 1993a) as a specific social system of domination in which ethnic groups and their members (i.e.majority) abuse their
power in various ways in interaction with other ethnic groups and their members (i.e. minority). Modern racism is hidden, so finding racism needs
special strategies in new texts and discourses. Elites have power, control, and access to media and they influence people. Van Dijk represents
Structures and strategies (reproduction of racism theory, 1993a) finding racism which consists of surface Structures and meaning (deep) Structures.
In this research, Donald Trump’s speeches about immigrants in the election (2016, SEP) taken from New York Times were analyzed based on Van
Dijk
’
s structures and strategies to find these structures in Trump
’
s speeches. The findings of this research show that Trump considers religion,
nationality, and culture of immigrants as well. Moreover, many surfaces and meaning structures are found in Trump
’
s lectures with different
frequencies. The results of this research are concordant with Van Dijk
’
s researches on racism.
Keywords: Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA), Elites, Donald Trump, Teun.A.Van Dijk, Racism, Surface and Meaning (Deep) Structures.
© 2020 The Authors. Published by Advance Scientific Research . This is an open-access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22159/jcr.07.01.01
INTRODUCTION
There are immigrants, refugees, and generally the minority existing in
all of the countries. It highly depends on the elites and their role in the
reproduction of racism when treating the minority. Therefore, if elites
believe in racism ideology, the people will behave disgracefully and
inappropriately toward the minority due to the power, control, access
to media, and influence of elites over people. In some cases, this
behavior may be such violent that leads to the death of the minority
members. Politicians, scientists, teachers, journalists, and managers of
companies can be called as elites. Nowadays, speeches of such political
elites such as Donald Trump, the president of the United States, contain
subtle(hidden) racism concepts and people cannot simply understand
them. These people may be affected by unknowingly and negatively by
such words. Therefore, specialized persons such as linguists, especially
scholars of interdisciplinary major of Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA)
who can clarify the meaning and ideologies behind the texts and
speeches uttered by politicians. In this case, people will less be affected
negatively.
Trumps’ speeches about immigrants can be evaluated based on the
racism field because he not only is against the entrance and acceptance
of immigrants but also considers religion, nationality, culture, values,
and beliefs of immigrants as significant metrics for the reception of
them.
This study was conducted based on the theoretical framework of Teun
A. van Dijk (Theory of Reproduction of Racism, 1993a). Van Dijk has
spent more than three decades on the study of racism. He believes that
there are structure and solutions including surface and meaning
(deep) structures used to find racism particularly hidden racism (Van
Dijk, 1993a). As a linguist, the author of this study analyzed Trump's
speeches about immigrants in the election (September 2016) taken
from the New York Times. This analysis was performed based on the
structures and strategies proposed by van Dijk (1993a) to find the
ideology behind the speeches of Trump. Some of Trump's speeches
were chosen to show his attention to religion, nationality, and culture
of immigrants. This study aimed to find the answer to the following
questions:
How can analyze the speeches of Trump in the light of Van Dijk’s
approach to racism?
How many surfaces and meaning structures of Van Dijk can be
found in Trump's discourse?
METHOD
Research data were collected from Trump's speeches about
immigrants during the election taken from New York Times website
(Donald Trump, September 2016). Purposive or judgmental sampling
method was used to select speeches about immigrants or the minority.
The research method of this paper was theoretical (based on the
argument), longitudinal (over a period), trend research (the study of
various samples with similar characteristics over time), documentary,
retrospective, and descriptive methodologies. The selected speeches
were analyzed critically based on the "structures and strategies" taken
from van Dijk's (1993a) approach to racism and methodology of
racism discovery.
Theoretical Framework (Van Dijk’ theory of reproduction of
racism, 1993a)
Critical discourse analysis (CDA) is a scientific and interdisciplinary
branch of linguistics, sociology, history, and social psychology that
examines the use of language in society. CDA approach studies the
language as a social practice concerning ideology, power, history, and
society at the discursive and textural levels of text (Aghagolzadeh,
2012, 11). Aghagolzadeh states about CDA, "It is a post-modernism
approach that is rooted in opinions of French philosopher, Michel
Foucault. This branch of linguistics assumes that some factors such as
historical structure, power-dominance relations, social, cultural, and
ideological institutes form new text or linguistic form, and meanings”
(Aghagolzadeh, 2012, 11).
CDA in linguistics tends to discover the reality of discourses using
linguistic strategies to help people grasp the right meanings hidden in
the text and discourse beyond the linguistic form.
CDA introduces the implicit power of discourses employing linguistics
strategies. According to this approach, the text and its meaning
depending on the ideologies hidden in dominant social institutes.
Power, ideology, and hegemony are the most significant concepts in
this field.
Van Dijk was a professor of discourse studies at the University of
Amsterdam, Netherlands and now is an honorary professor of Pompeu
Fabra University, Barcelona, Spain. He has been studying the cognitive
psychology of discourse, literary theories, textual grammar, and
reproduction of racism in discourse. Dijk has published numerous