Electrochromic Performance of
Viologen-Modified Periodic Mesoporous
Nanocrystalline Anatase Electrodes
Sung Yeun Choi,
†
Marc Mamak,
†
Neil Coombs,
†
Naveen Chopra,
‡
and
Geoffrey A. Ozin*
,†
Materials Chemistry Research Group, Department of Chemistry, 80 St. George Street,
UniVersity of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5S 3H6, and Xerox Research
Centre of Canada, 2660 Speakman DriVe, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada L5K 2L1
Received April 6, 2004; Revised Manuscript Received May 20, 2004
ABSTRACT
We report for the first time on the electrochromic performance of viologen-modified periodic mesoporous nanocrystalline anatase, denoted
meso-nc-TiO
2
-V(2+). Electrodes fashioned from meso-nc-TiO
2
-V(2+) were found to display enhanced color contrast yet have similar conduction
band edge energy level and electron percolation ability as electrodes made from viologen-modified nanocrystalline titania, nc-TiO
2
-V(2+). This
performance can be attributed to the uniform and ordered mesopore architecture, the nanocrystalline anatase wall structure, and the large
accessible surface area for tethering viologen molecules.
With the explosive growth of broadband communications
and wireless technologies, the demand for inexpensive thin
film lightweight display devices with paper-like readability
and ultralow power consumption has increased. One promis-
ing technology is the electrochromic (EC) device based upon
dye-modified semiconductor electrodes. Such a device has
advantages compared to intercalation EC electrodes, based
on materials such as tungsten oxide, due to much improved
time response and enhanced color contrast especially for
display technologies such as electronic paper or billboards.
1-3
The heart of the device is a working electrode composed of
a nanocrystalline semiconductor, usually an n-type metal
oxide, which has been modified with an electrochromophoric
molecular species, most often a redox active viologen
derivative, chemically tethered to the surface of the nano-
crystalline electrode. The efficiency of this system is based
upon fast interfacial electron transfer between the nanocrys-
talline electrode and the anchored chromophore along with
optical amplification brought about by the large surface area
of the nanocrystals, which enables high chromophore loading
per unit area of the electrode.
1d
Nanocrystalline titania (nc-TiO
2
) has been successfully
used for this purpose, resulting in a high efficiency electro-
chromic device mainly due to the intrinsic properties of the
nanocrystalline titania electrode, such as transparency to
visible light, electronic conductivity, high surface affinity
toward certain ligands, and large surface area.
1-4
In this
context, mesoporous titania (meso-TiO
2
) is of considerable
interest because of its high surface area and uniform and
well-ordered mesopores, which should facilitate the entry
of dye molecules into pores and anchoring of them to anatase
nanocrystals that comprise the channel walls.
5
There are
many reports for the synthesis and photocatalytic/photoelec-
trochemical properties of meso-TiO
2
,
6,7
however, no reports
yet exist concerning its electrochromic (EC) behavior.
In this communication, we report for the first time on the
EC performance of a new generation of viologen-modified
periodic mesoporous nanocrystalline titania, meso-nc-TiO
2
-
V(2+), thin film electrodes, particularly concerning color
contrast and color switching speed, electrochemical redox
potentials and reversibility, transient absorption change
during cycling, and color cycling stability. The uniquely
robust channel walls of meso-nc-TiO
2
support a relatively
large average anatase crystallite size, which favorably
impacts electrochromic reversibility and overall cell perfor-
mance. The following abbreviations will be used throughout
the text to clearly distinguish the three types of titania that
we are concerned with, namely: nc-TiO
2
, conventional
nanocrystalline anatase titania; meso-TiO
2
, periodic meso-
porous titania calcined at 350 °C; meso-nc-TiO
2
, periodic
mesoporous titania calcined at 400 °C. Viologen-modified
analogues of these materials are denoted as nc-TiO
2
-V(2+),
meso-TiO
2
-V(2+), and meso-nc-TiO
2
-V(2+), respectively.
Meso-nc-TiO
2
thin film electrodes were prepared using
procedures described in a recent report.
8
Meso-nc-TiO
2
synthesized by this method utilizes 1-butanol as solvent and
has a 2-D structure with hexagonally close-packed mesopores
* Corresponding author E-mail: gozin@chem.utoronto.ca.
†
University of Toronto.
‡
XRCC.
NANO
LETTERS
2004
Vol. 4, No. 7
1231-1235
10.1021/nl049484d CCC: $27.50 © 2004 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 06/17/2004