TECHNICAL ARTICLE
The Effect of Temperature on the Tangent Modulus of Granular
Composite Sport Surfaces
J.W. Bridge
1,2,3
, M.L. Peterson
2,3
, and C.W. McIlwraith
4
1 Department of Manufacturing and Mechanical Engineering, Oregon Institute of Technology, Klamath Falls, OR
2 Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Maine, Orono, ME
3 Racing Surfaces Testing Laboratory, Orono, ME
4 Gail Holmes Equine Orthopaedic Research Center, Department of Clinical Sciences, Colorado State University, Fort Collins,CO
Keywords
Tangent Modulus, Vertical Stiffness, Granular
Composites, Paraffin and Microcrystalline
Wax, Synthetic Horse Tracks
Correspondence
J.W. Bridge,
Department of Manufacturing and
Mechanical Engineering,
Oregon Institute of Technology, Klamath
Falls, OR 97601
Email: john.bridge@oit.edu
Received: March 26, 2012; accepted: July 4,
2012
doi:10.1111/j.1747-1567.2012.00851.x
Abstract
A series of tests were conducted to determine the tangent modulus (vertical
stiffness) values for a wax-coated granular composite material. This material is
commonly used as the surface for Thoroughbred horse racetracks. The tangent
modulus is important in the vertical loading of the surface by the hoof for
a highly nonlinear material. Test temperatures span a range from 0 to 64
◦
C
and include the thermal transition regions of the wax coating obtained from
differential scanning calorimetry tests. These temperatures also include the
range of temperatures that are encountered during use. Creep tests were
conducted to obtain steady-state strain conditions at loads ranging from 0.89 to
4.45 kN, the latter load approximating the weight of a Thoroughbred racehorse.
Through-transmission ultrasonic waves were utilized to determine the tangent
modulus values. The tangent moduli ranged from 74 to 573 MPa for the
conditions tested. For all loads tested, a large decrease in modulus and decrease
in material nonlinearity occurred as temperatures increased from 20 to 32
◦
C.
This temperature range matches the first thermal transition temperature for
the wax coating of the track material. The results of this work provide a basis
for racetrack maintenance decisions that can eliminate potentially adverse
temperature effects and may reduce equine injuries.
Introduction
To date, nine Thoroughbred horse racetracks in North
America have switched from dirt surfaces to synthetic
granular composite surfaces in an effort to reduce
equine injuries (although one has recently switched
back to dirt). Subsequent synthetic track injury
reports have been promising; for example, following
the 2005–2006 winter–spring meet at Turfway Park
in Kentucky, fatal equine racing injuries dropped from
24 to 3.
1
Racing data collected in California between
2004 and 2009 has shown an average reduction in
Thoroughbred fatalities from 3.09 per 1000 racing
starts on dirt surfaces to 1.95 per 1000 racing starts on
synthetic surfaces.
2
These statistics may be attributed,
in part, to an improved track base installed during the
replacement of the existing dirt tracks but also due to
a more consistent racing surface.
3,4
The consistency of
the synthetic tracks is influenced by the hydrophobic
wax (or polymer)-coated materials that reduce the
effect of moisture, a primary variable in traditional
dirt and turf surfaces.
5
The construction of the synthetic track systems
generally consists of an approximately 250-mm
thick layer of synthetic granular track material that
rests on porous macadam (asphalt) or other porous
geotextile. Under this layer is stone/aggregate that
covers a network of drainage pipes.
6,7
The synthetic
material differs from dirt used in conventional
tracks as it generally contains silica sand, polymer
fibers, and rubber particles all of which is coated
with a hydrocarbon paraffin-based, high-oil content
wax. One representative track manufacturer cites
Experimental Techniques (2012) © 2012, Society for Experimental Mechanics 1