Sustainability Issues and Activities for the NSDL
David J. McArthur
Computer Science Department
University of North Carolina,
Wilmington
dmcarthur1@nc.rr.com
Sarah Giersch
Consultant
University of North Carolina,
Wilmington
sgiersch@bellsouth.net
Howard Burrows
Senior Researcher
Autonomous Undersea Systems
Institute
ghburrows@attbi.com
Abstract
This poster will review the work on sustainability of digital
libraries in the context of the NSF-supported National Science
Digital Library (NSDL) program. Applied to digital libraries,
sustainability is a broad term, referring to everything from
technical issues about the digital preservation of materials, to
the social questions surrounding the long-term accessibility of
resources to the public at large.
INTRODUCTION
The NSDL is a highly distributed and loosely coupled set of
digital collections, knit together by a centralized Core Integration
(CI) project that provides a common infrastructure for the
collections. Sustainability is especially important to the NSDL
since its mission is to become one of the premier sources of
digital educational materials in the country. To achieve this goal,
it will have to tackle issues of growth and long-term stability
from many perspectives. Overall, the NSDL faces at least two
kinds of sustainability problems: the NSDL as a whole must
grow and ensure the availability and preservation of digital
materials for users; and, the projects that provide NSDL with
content, services and tools must also acquire the financial and
social resources they will need to survive beyond their current
short-term funding.
ISSUES & ACTIVITIES
This poster will review the work of different NSDL groups
that are contributing ideas about sustainability—principally the
Sustainability Standing Committee (SSC), the Policy Committee
(PC) and the CI—and will discuss their recent plans, activities
and results. These include:
• Investigating traditional business models for the NSDL. As
a result of discussions begun at a workshop with educational
publishers [3], the NSDL has considered various
partnerships opportunities with the traditional publishing
community, which involve providing content or services to
generate revenue. The poster will summarize a number of
these alternatives, including: selective contributions from
publishers to the NSDL; using materials from NSDL
collections to provide digital collateral resources for
publishers’ e-books; and, the role the NSDL in providing an
intellectual “commons” through which new tools and
services could be developed for publishers and the digital
library community.
• Considering non-traditional business models for NSDL.
Traditional business models for the NSDL roughly equate to
ones where end-users pay either directly or indirectly (e.g.,
through institutional licenses). However, the NSDL is also
considering a number of more innovative approaches, such
as the possibility of large-scale public investments in the
national digital library infrastructure [1] on the ambitious
scale of the Land-Grant Colleges Act of the 19
th
century, as
well as open-source and open-access business models.
• Analyzing the business costs of building and maintaining a
large-scale digital library. Regardless of the revenue
streams the NSDL eventually establishes, it will also need a
good understanding of its costs, including not only one-time
and recurring requirements, but also the timing of these
funds, likely sources, and the obligations that may go with
support from various funding institutions. Recent NSDL
studies have begun to consider these issues.
• Establishing a Governance and Organization Task Force.
Pathways to Progress [2], established an interim governance
structure for the NSDL, and provided an action-plan for the
design and implementation of the federated library and its
infrastructure. A task force has been formed recently to
consider other governance models. The early thinking of
this group will be reviewed in the poster, keeping in mind
that no authoritative steps to reshape the current governance
structure, or establish a legal entity for the NSDL, are likely
to be taken for several years.
REFERENCES
[1] Grossman, K. and Minow, N. A Digital Gift to the Nation:
Fulfilling the Promise of the Digital and Internet Age. The
Century Foundation Press, New York, NY, 2001.
[2] Manduca, C., McMartin, F. and Mogk, D. Pathways to
Progress: Vision and Plan for Developing NSDL. (2001),
http://www.nsdl.org.
[3] McArthur, D., Giersch, S., Wittenberg, K. and Luby, M.
NSDL & Educational Publishers’ Workshop Report.
(Columbia University, October 2002),
http://publishers.comm.nsdlib.org
Proceedings of the 2003 Joint Conference on Digital Libraries (JCDL’03)
0-7695-1939-3/03 $17.00 © 2003 IEEE