The impact of experimental sedimentation and flooding on the growth and
germination of floodplain trees
Ramona L. Walls
1,2,
*
, Denice Heller Wardrop
1
and Robert P. Brooks
1
1
Penn State Cooperative Wetlands Center, 302 Walker Building, The Pennsylvania State University, University
Park, PA 16802, USA;
2
Current address: Department of Ecology and Evolution, State University of New York
Stony Brook, Life Sciences Building, Stony Brook, NY 11794-5245, USA;
*
Author for correspondence (tel.: 1
(516) 885-8005; fax: 1 (631) 632-7626)
Received 20 August 2002; accepted in revised form 23 March 2004
Key words: Acer rubrum, Fraxinus pennsylvanica, Quercus palustris, sediment, wetlands, floodplains, adventi-
tious roots
Abstract
Land-use changes in a forested floodplain’s watershed can lead to incremental changes in the hydrology and
sedimentation rates of the floodplain. The impacts of these changes can be difficult to measure due to the slow
response time of mature trees. Seedlings and saplings, on the other hand, may show an immediate response.
Responses during these early life history stages can have major consequences for regeneration of floodplain for-
ests and ultimately result in community alteration. This study tested the importance of changes in hydrology and
sedimentation on the germination and growth rates of three common floodplain tree species: Acer rubrum, Fraxi-
nus pennsylvanica and Quercus palustris. Two-year-old saplings were grown in a greenhouse under two hydro-
logic regimes, with or without the addition of sediment. Neither periodic flooding with or without sediment nor
static flooding on its own affected the growth of the seedlings. With the addition of sediment, static flooding for
two weeks lead to a significant decrease in sapling growth. There was a significant species x treatment interac-
tion, suggesting that each species responded differently to the application of flooding and sediment. The timing
of germination and the total percent germination for F. pennsylvanica and Q. palustris seeds were tested under
the same conditions. Flooding and sediment acted in an additive manner to delay the germination of both F.
pennsylvanica and Q. palustris and to reduce the total germination rate of Q. palustris. There was no difference
in the total germination rate of F. pennsylvanica seeds under any treatment. During the growth trials, adventitious
roots sprouted on saplings grown under sedimentation. Adventitious roots growing into sediment rather than
floodwater should be able to utilize the sediment’s nutrients and may compensate for some of the stress of flood-
ing. The results of this study suggest that sediment tolerances will vary among species, but will not necessarily
correlate with flood tolerances, and that sedimentation may be as important as flooding in determining floodplain
plant community composition.
Introduction
Riparian forests are the most extensive class of wet-
lands in the contiguous United States Mitsch and
Gosselink 2000. They play an important role in pro-
viding wildlife habitat, maintaining water quality and
preventing catastrophic flooding Johnson and Mc-
Cormick 1979; Taylor et al. 1990; Jordan et al. 2003.
Riparian forests are part of the hydrogeomorphic
class of mainstem floodplains, wetlands whose
primary structuring factors are their sedimentation
and hydrologic regimes Golet et al. 1993; Cole et al.
1997; Lenssen et al. 1999. Floodplains in the north-
eastern United States are situated in historically for-
Plant Ecology 2005 176:203-213
© Springer 2005