Precision Engineering 35 (2011) 339–347
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Precision Engineering
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/precision
A novel method of determination of wire lag for enhanced profile accuracy in
WEDM
S. Sarkar
a,∗
, M. Sekh
b
, S. Mitra
a
, B. Bhattacharyya
a
a
Production Engineering Department, Jadavpur University, Kolkata 700032, India
b
Production Engineering Department, H.I.T., Midnapore(E) 721657, India
article info
Article history:
Received 4 April 2010
Received in revised form 20 October 2010
Accepted 6 January 2011
Available online 13 January 2011
Keywords:
WEDM
Wire offset
Profile accuracy
Wire lag compensation
Gap force
abstract
Wire bending due to gap force is a major cause of imprecision in WEDM applications. To achieve higher
precision and accuracy the knowledge of gap force and wire lag is extremely essential. In the present
research, an in depth study on wire lag phenomenon has been carried out. A novel method to measure
gap force intensity and wire lag under any given machining condition has been proposed by developing
an analytical model. Experiments were carried out to verify the proposed model. Beside this, the impact
of wire deflection on profile accuracy during cutting cylindrical job has been investigated. Based upon the
developed analytical model an effective method has been proposed to eliminate this inaccuracy using
wire lag compensation technique. The research finding will lead to better understanding of the gap force
phenomena and will promote significant development in the domain of high precision WEDM.
© 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The cutting speed, surface finish and taper angle are improving
markedly day by day since the beginning of wire electrical dis-
charge machining (WEDM). But, wire bending, which is a major
cause of cutting imprecision, is still hampering the part accuracy
for various applications. When cutting out a sharp corner or curved
profile, the bending of the wire creates a geometrical error on
the workpiece. This error can be of the order of a few hundred
microns; which for some applications becomes unacceptable [1].
Several research efforts have been given for improving the accu-
racy in WEDM. Dekeyser and Snoeys [2] proposed off-line path
modification strategy to enhance the profile accuracy. Later Dauw
and Beltrami [1] developed on line wire path control system using
an on line optical wire position sensor. Hsue et al. [3] addressed
the unsteady phenomena of the machining parameters at the cor-
ner using the concept of discharge angle. To reduce the machining
errors of corner parts, Lin et al. [4] developed a fuzzy control strat-
egy to improve corner accuracy through reduction of wire lag near
corner by increasing the pulse off time. Using Taguchi method-
ology Puri and Bhattaharyya [5] minimized corner inaccuracy in
trim cutting operation through optimization of process parame-
ters. Sanchez et al. [6] proposed a technological data base system
in which experimental knowledge and numerical simulation of the
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: mail.dr.sarkar@gmail.com (S. Sarkar).
process allow the user to select the optimum cutting strategy, either
by wire path modification or by cutting regime modification. Yan
et al. [7] claimed improvement in corner accuracy using on line
closed loop wire tension control system. A corner error simulation
method was proposed by Fuzhu et al. [8] to predict the actual corner
profile under different cutting condition. Sanchez et al. [9] studied
how the number of finishing cut and cutting speed limitation influ-
ences the corner accuracy on different thickness workpiece. Lin
and Liao [10] proposed an effective-wire-compensation scheme to
specify the wire location matrices required to improve the precision
of the machining results while manufacturing components with
tapered features or complex profile. Dodun et al. [11] investigated
the error in machining of small corner angle in thin parts.
From the review of the past research, it is found that the pro-
cedure to improve accuracy can broadly be classified in to two
categories. The first procedure is to modify the cutting parame-
ters (pulse on time, pulse off time peak current etc.) in order to
reduce the wire deflection [2,4–6,9]. This methods result in low-
ering of cutting speed at the corner. The second procedure is to
modify the wire path to correct the geometrical inaccuracy in an
on-line [1,6,11] manner. In the second procedure, although the cut-
ting speed is not reduced but accuracy level is comparatively poor
compared to first procedure for smaller angle [6]. To implement
the either of the above procedure the knowledge of wire deflec-
tion for a given machining parameter setting is extremely essential.
Some researchers attempted to measure the wire displacement
using optical sensor [1] or electrical contact between wire and
workpiece [12]. But it is not an easy task to measure the wire posi-
0141-6359/$ – see front matter © 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.precisioneng.2011.01.001