A Critical Look at the Sustainable Development Goals
from an Experience Carried Out by Elementary School
Students: To Be or Not to Be, Is That the Question
Una mirada crítica a los objetivos de desarrollo
sostenible a partir de una experiencia realizada por
estudiantes de primaria: ¿ser o no ser, esa es la cuestión?
Alynne de Oliveira¹, Beatriz Rodrigues¹, Victória Rodrigues¹,
Kelly Pinheiro dos Santos¹, Laísa Maria Freire¹, Cristian Merino²
¹ Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro
² Pontifcia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso
Abstract
Tis study analyzes the limitations, possibilities, conditioning factors, and qualitative
substrates for the signifcance of sustainability approaches in global discourses such as the
17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDG). In order to do this, an Environmental Education
workshop was held with elementary students in two public schools in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Te students (n = 103) were divided into fve groups. Each group received a kit containing a
photograph of a work of art, a photograph of Rio de Janeiro, and a news report. As a result
of the activity, the participants made a drawing about the construction of a sustainable
world. In order to identify their drawings, a qualitative analysis strategy was used through
systemic networks and classifcation into levels of representation. Te results indicate that
the students relate some SDGs to each other, although the drawings concentrated on the
level of representation as description. In School 2, greater sophistication and complexity are
observed in the drawings, which include symbolic, syntactic, and semantic aspects. Finally,
the conclusions indicate that the drawings include imperative verbs, prescribing modes of
change and action for the children to participate.
Keywords: ecopedagogy, environmental education, drawing analysis, sustainability, sustainable
development goals.
Post to:
Alynne de Oliveira
Laboratório de Limnologia da UFRJ. Avenida Carlos Chagas Filho, 373, Edifício do
CCS, Bloco A, Sub-Solo, Sala A0-008 - Cidade Universitária, Ilha do Fundão, Rio de
Janeiro/RJ CEP: 21.949-900, Brasil.
oli.alynne@gmail.com
Financiamiento asociado: Proyecto de extensión “Vida en el agua, agua en
la vida: entrelazando la educación ambiental y la divulgación de la ciencia,
la universidad y la escuela” - Universidad Federal de Río de Janeiro (UFRJ);
Proyecto PIBID/CAPES 2018-2019 Número del proceso: 88882.215740/2018-
01; Coordinación para el Mejoramiento del Personal de Educación Superior -
Brasil (CAPES/Print) - Número del proceso: 88881.312004/2018-01; Programa
Institucional de Internacionalización (CAPES/PRINT) Número de proceso:
88887.466572/2019-00; Proyecto Fondecyt 1180619 (ANID, Gobierno de Chile).
© 2020 PEL, http://www.pensamientoeducativo.org - http://www.pel.cl
ISSN:0719-0409 DDI:203.262, Santiago, Chile doi: 10.7764/PEL.57.2.2020.7
Pensamiento Educativo. Revista de Investigación Educacional Latinoamericana
2020, 57(2), 1-23