Biotechnology Letters 23: 317–324, 2001.
© 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
317
Characterization of plant suspension cultures using the focused beam
reflectance technique
Karen A. McDonald
*
, Alan P. Jackman & Shaelyn Hurst
Department of Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, University of California, Davis, CA 95616, USA
*
Author for correspondence (Fax: +530 752 1031; E-mail: kamcdonald@ucdavis.edu)
Received 2 October 2000; Revisions requested 19 October 2000; Revisions received 1 December 2000; Accepted 2 December 2000
Key words: aggregate size, bioreactor monitoring, plant cell culture
Abstract
Development of bioreactor systems utilizing plant suspension cultures has been hindered by the lack of on-line
sensors for monitoring important process variables such as biomass concentration and aggregate size. An optical
technique, the focused beam reflectance method (FBRM developed by Lasentec Inc., Redmond, WA), was used
to characterize several plant suspension cultures: rice (Oryza sativa), tobacco (Nicotiana benthamiana) and wild
Chinese cucumber (Trichosanthes kirilowii). These cultures differ in a number of respects such as individual cell
size and morphology, aggregate shape and size distribution, initial culture density, and color. For plant suspensions
comprised of relatively spherical aggregates (rice and cucumber), the area under the cube-weighted FBRM chord
length distribution was linearly correlated to biomass concentration (R
2
> 0.99) while the mean of the cube-
weighted FBRM chord length distribution was nonlinearly related to aggregate size.
Introduction
Plant suspension cultures are currently being investi-
gated as a source of novel and commercially important
natural compounds as well as for production of re-
combinant proteins using transgenic plant cell lines
(see review by Fischer et al. 1999). Advantages of
plant cultures over other host cells include their abil-
ity to grow well in suspension in relatively inexpen-
sive, chemically defined media, capacity for complex
glycosylation, ease of scale-up compared with mam-
malian host cells, and safety (plants are not known
to propagate human pathogens). However, plant cells
typically grow as aggregates rather than single cells.
Aggregate size distribution not only plays an impor-
tant role in mixing, oxygen and nutrient mass transfer,
and ease of product purification, but in many cases it
is directly related to productivity. For example, Pépin
et al. (1999) and Kinnersley & Dougall (1980) have
shown that the production of the pigment anthocyanin
from plant suspension cultures is inversely related to
aggregate size. In contrast, Jianfeng et al. (1998) have
shown that the production of the secondary metabo-
lite salidroside is significantly increased in 3–7 mm
compact callus aggregates compared with dispersed
cells.
While there are a number of bioreactor variables
that can easily be monitored on-line, sensors for in-
situ monitoring of the two most critical variables for
plant suspension cultures, biomass concentration and
aggregate size are lacking. Although there are sev-
eral ways to characterize biomass concentration in
plant suspension cultures, dry weight measurements
are often considered to be the most meaningful and
reliable. However this method requires sampling the
bioreactor and takes 1–3 days to obtain a measurement
minimizing the measurement’s usefulness for on-line
control. Similarly, aggregate size distribution is often
measured by gently screening a sample from the biore-
actor using a series of standard sieves and obtaining
the dry weight of the biomass retained on each screen.
In addition to the disadvantages described above, the
mechanical sieving process has the potential to al-
ter the size distribution. Thus, in-situ techniques to
monitor biomass concentration (dry weight l
-1
) and