Service Quality in Academia: A South African Experience
Kem Ramdass
Faculty of Arts, Design and Architecture, University of Johannesburg, South Africa
Abstract--As competition intensifies and environmental
factors become more hostile, the concern for service quality
grows. Student numbers have become a focal point in the
offering of programmes. With regular quality audits, academia
prioritises the fulfillment of the HEQC criteria, but lacks the
provision of service quality to the student. If service quality is to
become the cornerstone of marketing strategy, the marketer
must have the means that differentiates the different academic
institutions in SA.
Service quality is considered a critical determinant of
competitiveness. Attention to "service quality" can help an
organisation to differentiate itself from other organisations and
through it gain a lasting competitive advantage. High quality of
service is considered an essential determinant of the long-term
profitability not only of service organisations, but also of
manufacturing organisations. In some manufacturing industries
"service quality" is considered a more important order winner
than "product quality". Superior "service quality" is a key to
improved profitability, and not the cost of doing business.
Exemplary service is the next sale in the making. The
methodology of the research comprises a qualitative,
exploratory and descriptive design. Relevant literature in
conjunction with national and international trends was used to
understand how best practices could be employed.
I. BACKGROUND AND METHODOLOGY
South Africa is a multicultural democracy of
approximately 44 million people, and is geographically
located at the southern nib of Africa. Until 1994, the
apartheid ideology created a scenario of inferior educational
opportunities to people of colour. Education was often
highlighted by protest action by the disadvantaged
population. In particular, the teaching of the Afrikaans
language was rejected by generations of secondary students.
Tertiary education reinforced race and class differences under
apartheid. Disparities in resource distribution and the
curricula offered maintained the apartheid mentality.
Higher education in the developing countries of Africa is
a force in the national socio-economic development of
countries against a backdrop of oppression, ignorance and
eternal dependence. Therefore, attention should be paid to a
curriculum that would be able to develop the needs of the
skills demand in the country. In South Africa, development
strategies from an educational perspective, which stress
issues such as social equality, rural development and the
eradication of poverty and diseases, are most applicable. As
such, this looks at a distinctive view of the nature of quality
and its implementation, thus embedding appropriate ways in
the quality of teaching, learning, assessment and the
curriculum. The National Qualifications Framework (NQF)
takes a holistic view of the personal, social, and economic
needs of the South African society in view of skills over
formal knowledge. The NQF endorses an outcomes-based
approach due to the growing concern about the effectiveness
of traditional methods of teaching and training, which is
content-based [6]. The purpose of the change is to promote
overall improvement in the level of skills of the workforce,
thus contributing to the productivity level in South Africa.
The methodology of the research comprises a qualitative,
exploratory and descriptive design. A questionnaire was used
to gain insight into the experiences of first year students.
Relevant literature in conjunction with national and
international trends was used to understand how best
practices could be employed.
II. INTRODUCTION
The business of education can be described as a service, a
service which is directly impacted on by the provider of
education. Higher education institutions are placing greater
emphasis on meeting students' expectations and needs. As
universities continue to become more student oriented,
student perceptions of higher educational facilities and
services are becoming more important. Educational service
quality, emphasizing student satisfaction, is a newly
emerging field of concern both nationally and internationally.
Interest in the measurement of service quality is high,
however, as highlighted by several researchers, service
quality is an elusive and abstract concept that is difficult to
define and measure [1]. This is because of the fact that once a
service is delivered it cannot be returned, reworked or
prevented from reaching the customer. A serviced delivered
cannot be taken back and because of this reason it is critical
to provide a service correctly, meeting customer needs, the
first time around. Failure to do so may well result in an
unsatisfied customer who may not only want to do business
with the organization again, but may influence the decision of
potential customers [2]. Also given the intangible nature of a
service in comparison to a product, measuring conformance
is difficult and may only be done after the fact. Yet again this
demonstrates the necessity to “get it right the first time
around.”
III. LITERATURE REVIEW
Education has become a primary focus for the SA
government as the country grapples with skill shortages.
Government policy since 1994 has strongly focused on
repositioning higher education in terms of global
technological and economic competitiveness. However there
has been tension in terms of sector prioritization. The dual
challenge that higher education institutions face is firstly to
1655
PICMET 2010 Proceedings, July 18-22, Phuket, Thailand © 2010 PICMET