Exaggerated Differences in Pulse Wave Velocity Between Left and Right Sides
Among Patients With Anxiety Disorders and Cardiovascular Disease
VIKRAM KUMAR YERAGANI, MBBS, FRCP(C), RAHUL KUMAR, MD, KARL JUERGEN BAR, MD, PRATAP CHOKKA, MD,
AND MANUEL TANCER, MD
Objective: To compare the left-right differences in pulse wave velocity (PWV) measures in normal controls and patients with
anxiety disorders and cardiac disease. Pulses from the right and left sides of normal subjects are highly correlated at each segmental
level. However, some evidence suggests that the right hemisphere has a greater effect on parasympathetic activity, as there may be
a right hemisphere disadvantage in patients with low cardiac vagal function. Decreased vagal function is associated with vascular
dysfunction and hypertension. Methods: We compared normal controls (n = 22), patients with anxiety (n = 26), and patients with
cardiovascular disease (n = 72) using the Vascular Profiler (VP-1000), which enables the measurement of ankle and brachial blood
pressure (BP) in both arms (brachial), both legs (ankle) and carotid artery, and lead I electrocardiogram and phonocardiogram.
Using these signals, PWV, and arterial stiffness index % were calculated for the comparison of these measures on the right and left
sides of the body. Results: Patients with anxiety and cardiovascular disease had significantly higher left-right differences in
heart-ankle pulse wave velocity, brachial-ankle pulse wave velocity, and arterial stiffness index percentage compared with that of
normal controls. Our data also showed significant differences between left-right vascular indices in patients with anxiety and
cardiovascular disease (p .00001); there was no such significant difference in normal controls. Conclusions: These results may
implicate an exaggerated vagal withdrawal in the left extremities resulting in higher PWV in patients with anxiety and
cardiovascular illness. Key words: pulse wave velocity, autonomic function, atherosclerosis, arterial stiffness index, cardiovascular
mortality, anxiety.
HR = heart rate; BP = blood pressure; PWV = pulse wave velocity;
HF = high frequency (0.15– 0.5 Hz); PTT = pulse transit time;
HA = heart-ankle; BA = brachial-ankle; ECG = electrocardiogram;
PCG = phonocardiogram; VP = vascular profiler; BMDP = bio-
medical data package; ANOVA = analysis of variance; MAP =
mean arterial pressure; PEP = pre-ejection period; GAD = gener-
alized anxiety disorder.
INTRODUCTION
P
hotoplethysmography pulse signals are body site specific
and show differences in pulse transit time, strength and
shape, and variation of each over time. A recent study showed
a high degree of correlation between the right and the left side
signals (1). However, Erciyas et al. (2) reported a more sig-
nificant suppression of vagal parasympathetic activity in
stroke patients with right hemispheric lesions, which led them
to conclude that the right hemisphere seemed to have a greater
effect on parasympathetic activity. Malaspina et al. (3) also
suggested a connection between right hemisphere disadvan-
tage and low vagal cardiac function. On the other hand,
Wittling et al. (4) reported that control of autonomic cardiac
activity at the level of the cerebral cortex seemed to be
characterized by a division of responsibility between the two
hemispheres, sympathetic activity being mainly controlled by
the right hemisphere and parasympathetic activity, by the left
hemisphere. Bar et al. (5) examined the laterality of pupillary
light reflexes and found differences between both eyes, sug-
gesting cortical localization of central autonomic function. In
another recent study, Foster and Harrison (6) found evidence
for cerebral asymmetry in the regulation of heart rate (HR)
and blood pressure (BP). However, we were unable to find
any studies that compared the left-right differences in normal
controls and patients with either psychiatric or cardiovascular
disease without any apparent cerebral lesions.
Some studies suggest a decrease in cardiac vagal function
in conditions such as anxiety disorders, hypertension, and
several cardiac diseases including coronary artery disease
(7–12). This is important in light of the association between
anxiety and an increase in cardiovascular mortality and sud-
den death (13–16). In a recent study, we found significant
correlations between pulse wave velocity (PWV) and R-R
interval (interbeat interval) high frequency (HF) (0.15– 0.5
Hz) variability in patients with anxiety, which suggest de-
creased cardiac vagal function in these patients (17). PWV is
an important noninvasive marker of atherosclerosis (18 –21).
PWV indicates the speed at which the pulse is transmitted
from the heart to the end artery when blood is expelled during
cardiac contraction. PWV is the most widely used measure of
arterial stiffness in different clinical fields (22). The stiffer the arterial
wall, the faster the arterial wave travels through the arterial
wall. Carotid-femoral PWV reflects the stiffness of the large
elastic arteries and is the most widely used measure of arterial
stiffness. This is due to the fact that the atherosclerotic
changes of the arterial wall begin at the aorta and stiffness of
the aorta is related to cardiac afterload (23). Carotid-femoral
PWV is useful in identifying patients with atherosclerosis as
well as patients with a poor prognosis in cardiac disease
(21,24 –26). Brachial-ankle PWV (BAPWV), which is derived
from the heart-brachial and heart-ankle PWV (HBPWV and
HAPWV) is a measure of arterial stiffness (27) and its phys-
iological characteristics are closer to carotid-femoral PWV
than to femoral ankle PWV (28). The reproducibility of this
measure is good (27) and recent data suggest that higher
values of BAPWV are associated with more advanced
From the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Neurosciences (V.K.Y.,
M.T.), Wayne State University School of Medicine, Detroit, Michigan; Insti-
tute of Cardiology (V.K.Y., R.K.), M.S. Ramaiah Institute of Cardiology,
Bangalore, India; Department of Psychiatry (V.K.Y., P.C.), University of
Alberta (V.K.Y., P.C.), Edmonton, Alberta, Canada; and Department of
Psychiatry (K.J.B.), Friedrich Schiller University, Jena, Germany.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to V. K. Yeragani, #411,
11135-83 Avenue, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada T6G 2C6. E-mail:
Vikramyershr@yahoo.com
Received for publication September 18, 2006; revision received June 9,
2007.
DOI: 10.1097/PSY.0b013e3181574272
717 Psychosomatic Medicine 69:717–722 (2007)
0033-3174/07/6907-0717
Copyright © 2007 by the American Psychosomatic Society