Twice-Exceptional
Learners: Effects of Teacher
Preparation and Disability
Labels on Gifted Referrals
Teacher Education and Special Education
33(4)319-334
© 2010 Teacher Education Division of
the Council for Exceptional Chiidren
Reprints and pernnission:
sagepub.com/journaisPermlssions.nav
DOi: 10.1177/0888406409356392
http://tese.sagepub.com
tSAGE
Margarita Bianco' and Nancy L. Leech'
Abstract
The goal of this mixed methods study was to explore differences among teachers (n = 52 special
education teachers, n = 195 general education teachers, and n = 30 gifted education teachers) on
their perceptions of students with disabilities and their willingness to refer them to a gifted and
talented program. In this follow-up to an earlier work, data reveal that teachers' decisions for
referral are significantly influenced by their teaching credentials and by the presence or absence
of a disability label. When compared to teachers of gifted students and general education
teachers, special education teachers are least likely to refer students to a gifted program, with
disabilities and without. Results further indicate that all teachers are much less willing to refer
students with disability labels to gifted programs than identically described students with no
disability labels.
Keywords
twice-exceptional, gifted, teacher perceptions, gifted referrals
The potential for giftedness exists in all seg-
ments of the population, including students
with disabilities. For many reasons, students
with disabilities—or twice-exceptional
learners—remain underrepresented and under-
served in gifted programs throughout the
country (Davis & Rimm, 2004; L. J. Johnson,
Kames, & Carr, 1997). Given that one of the
most common methods for screening students
for gifted identification includes teachers'
observations and nominations (Davis &
Rimm, 2004; Hallahan, Kauffman, & Pullen,
2009), teachers' perceptions of students with
disabilities and their knowledge of gifted
characteristics become a critical component
for initial identification of potential giftedness
among twice-exceptional learners.
Twice-exceptional students have been
described as students "with special intellectual-
processing problems [leaming, commtinication.
and/or behavioral disabilities] that neverthe-
less, maintain an extraordinary high general
intellectual potential" (Gallagher, 1988, p. 110).
In the absence of accurate prevalence data, the
highest incidence of giftedness among students
with disabilities is most likely among students
with leaming disabilities (LDs; Miller & Terry-
Godt, 1996), given the increased attention in
identifying characteristics of this subpopula-
tion of twice-exceptional learners. For many
gifted students with LDs and other twice-
exceptional learners, the students' disabilities
frequently mask their gifted abilities, thus
causing both exceptionalities to appear less
'University of Colorado, Denver, Colorado, USA
Corresponding Author:
Margarita Bianco 1380 Lawrence Street, Campus Box
106, Denver, CO 80217
Margarita.Bianco@ucdenver.edu